Dealership car care or mechanic shop?

Imo I prefer the dealer. I feel as though yes some parts are expensive at the dealership but they have a better quality of work. They make sure the car is in tip top condition before its given back to you. They will fix any issues that THEY caused with no questions asked and in most cases, you dont have to pay anything. Plus, I feel like who better to work on my car than the actual place that it came from?!

At a mechanic shop parts may be cheaper but their quality of work isn’t the greatest. They rush things and dont own up to mistakes they make. They also dont fix mess ups that they caused like the dealership does. Often times you will pay for it as well.

This is just imo, let me know yours in the comments.

#letschat #suvlife #momcar #lemon8creator

2025/2/4 Edited to

... Read moreWhen it comes to vehicle care, the debate between using a dealership or a local mechanic shop is common. Dealerships often offer manufacturer-trained technicians who use original parts and are well-acquainted with your vehicle model. This tailored service typically ensures higher quality repairs, as they adhere to specific maintenance guidelines set by the car manufacturer. Moreover, dealerships may provide certain warranties on their work, giving car owners peace of mind that any issues traced back to their repairs will be addressed without additional costs. On the other hand, local mechanic shops can attract customers due to their more competitive pricing for parts and labor. Many independent mechanics are highly skilled and provide personalized service that many customers appreciate. However, it is essential to consider that not all shops adhere to the same quality standards, and not all mechanics have the same level of expertise as those at dealerships. A cheaper price can sometimes lead to a compromise on the quality of the parts used or the thoroughness of the repairs, which might incur additional costs later on. For those who own a brand new vehicle, it often makes sense to stick with the dealership for the initial years of service while the car is under warranty. However, as the vehicle ages, some drivers may find it more cost-effective to explore local mechanics that can offer reliable services for older models. Ultimately, the decision between a dealership and a mechanic shop should be guided by factors such as vehicle age, warranty status, repair complexity, and personal experiences. Don't hesitate to share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!

119 comments

HujxS🤍's images
HujxS🤍

I think it depends on the car tbh. If you have a newer/ more expensive car or you got it from a dealer that does maintenance and repairs then it make sense to get it done there, but if you have an older car or you bought it second hand, personally I would just take it somewhere cheaper for basic stuff like (1)

See more(4)
Olivia Jesse's images
Olivia Jesse

It really depends on the age of your car and/or if your car is considered a luxury class or specialty vehicle with hard to find parts. If your car is brand new, the dealer will treat you better, within the first 3 years of the cars life and while your car is under warranty.

See more(2)

See more comments

Related posts

A car dealership interior with a red car and a white SUV, featuring the title 'Guide to Start your career at a dealership SWIPE' in white text with sparkle accents.
Text outlines dealership departments: Sales, Service, and Accounting/assistant positions. It notes that a degree is often not needed and advises choosing a vehicle brand for passion and pricing.
Text explains that experience from other dealers or car shops is typically sufficient, emphasizing flexibility and that specific qualifications are often not required for roles, with a Lemon8 license plate graphic.
Car Dealership Career Guide
As someone who has worked in dealerships for many years now here is a beginner guide if you are thinking about getting started on a career at one! #lemon8career #cardealershiplife #careeradvice #lemon8careers
Lemon472687182275

Lemon472687182275

32 likes

Think all oil changes are the same? Let’s talk about it. 👇 #oilchange #mechanic #dealership #mechaniclife
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

0 likes

🚗🔧 CAR DEALERSHIP SERVICE HORROR STORIES
I went down the Reddit rabbit hole and found some absolutely wild stories about people’s experiences with dealership service departments. 😳 Bad repairs. 💸 Shocking service bills. 🔧 Cars coming back with NEW problems. 🤯 And some situations that are almost impossible to believe. I’m reading
Travelandlivelife

Travelandlivelife

2 likes

Do you guys prefertaking your car tothe dealership
#gettoknowme
Beatrice 2001

Beatrice 2001

0 likes

Maria Cruz

Maria Cruz

1 like

Do you guys prefertaking your car tothe dealership
#springoutfit
Lemoo

Lemoo

1 like

Working at a car dealership as a 19yr old
Follow me to support my journey. #dealershiplife #cardealership #sales
slywiththesales

slywiththesales

3 likes

Spend the day with me as a successful black female car dealer #fypシ #foryou #cardealer
StarEricka

StarEricka

0 likes

These men out here are SCAMMERS #carfax #usedcars #carshopping #facebookmarketplace
arfidawarenesss

arfidawarenesss

0 likes

🚗⚠️ Worst Car Dealership Experience
I never thought I’d have to share something like this, but I feel it’s important to warn others. I went to a dealership expecting a normal car-shopping experience. Instead, it turned into one of the most uncomfortable situations I’ve ever been in at a dealership. After arriving, the salesman
Genesha

Genesha

0 likes

A light green background features dark green text asking about car maintenance preferences between dealerships and regular mechanics, and if dealerships are worth the extra cost. A green passport illustration with yellow stars is in the bottom right, and 'Lemons @beau.howard62' is in the bottom left.
Do you guys prefertaking your car tothe dealership
Beau Howard

Beau Howard

1 like

Do you agree with their picks? #mechanic #dealership #mechaniclife #mechanicsoftiktok #mechanics
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

0 likes

Rosemary Wahl

Rosemary Wahl

0 likes

Who's this man at the dealership? 👀
#tarot #divination #dealership #tarotcards #tarotdeck
🦚Little Bird🦚

🦚Little Bird🦚

1 like

What Your Car Says About You! - via the Dealership
So let’s start this off with I’ve been in the car business my entire life. I grew up in a mechanics shop and then have been working in dealerships for 12 years. These are the top 9 cars sold this year and if you bought one, this is what people in dealerships think about you. Ford F-150 “You be
Jesse Allen

Jesse Allen

126 likes

How I Became a Car Salesman!
Let me know in the comments if you’re currently a sales professional are aren’t! #Carsales #Dealership #Saratoga #Albany #NYC
Jose Benitez

Jose Benitez

1 like

Tips from a certified technician at a dealership!
If y'all got questions on maintenance. Feel free to let me know. I can make a new one to break more things down for you and make sure you're not getting scamed! Lakeland #certifiedmechanic
J.k.hhz

J.k.hhz

9 likes

A black car with neon pink text "The Dealership IS SCAMMING YOU !" above it and neon green text "FINANCE SECRETS" on its windshield, set on a street with houses.
The interior of a car with an open door, showing the steering wheel and red-accented seats. Text highlights three ways people are taken advantage of: "1 DOWN PAYMENT", "2 DEALERSHIP & BANK RELATIONSHIP", and "3 FINANCIAL IMPACT".
The side of a black car, focusing on the front wheel. Text advises to "SAVE THIS POST" and "READ THE DESCRIPTION BELOW" for explanations, with a large white arrow pointing downwards.
The Dealership Is Scamming You
@Welcome Baddies It is very unfortunate that we as a society have been conditioned to thrive inside the box rather than stepping out and examining all angles. Today I have decided to take a peek outside the box and I am asking my fellow comradorates on Lemon8 to come along with me. It is my
Welcome Baddies

Welcome Baddies

1716 likes

Keep up the great work in there! #dealership #mechanic #carhumor #comedy #fyp
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

0 likes

A promotional graphic for an automotive facility for lease at 6212 S Rice Ave, Houston, TX. It shows a street-level view of the building with a 'FOR LEASE' sign and an aerial view of the property with a large car lot. The 9,500-11,700 SF space is ideal for auto dealerships, mechanic shops, or body shops.
FOR LEASE Auto Mechanic/ Auto BodyShop/ Fleet
FOR LEASE | 6212 S Rice Ave, Houston, TX 77081 Position your business in one of Southwest Houston’s most active and densely populated corridors. This highly visible commercial property offers a rare opportunity for automotive, service, or flex users seeking strong traffic exposure and a function
Real Estate Cynthia

Real Estate Cynthia

0 likes

FOR LEASE Auto Mechanic/ Auto BodyShop/ Fleet
FOR LEASE | 6212 S Rice Ave, Houston, TX 77081 Position your business in one of Southwest Houston’s most active and densely populated corridors. This highly visible commercial property offers a rare opportunity for automotive, service, or flex users seeking strong traffic exposure and a function
Real Estate Cynthia

Real Estate Cynthia

0 likes

Why not to be a mechanic anymore!
This is one of the biggest issues that technicians face in the dealership world. A typical mechanic gets paid as flat rate, not hourly. That means he’s only getting paid for what the job pays. So if the job pays 2hrs and he takes 6hrs he only gets paid 2hrs, however if he takes an hour he gets paid
Krisbuchowicz

Krisbuchowicz

50 likes

Do you agree? #mechanic #mechaniclife #dealership #mechanicsoftiktok #technician
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

1 like

Just repeating what I heard 🤷‍♀️ #mechanic #mechanictok #dealership #liloandstitch #fyp
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

1289 likes

Auto Detailing Specialist
lover4life

lover4life

5 likes

A day in my life as a serial entrepreneur juggling multiple businesses ❤️❤️ #serialentreprenuer #dayinmylife #vlog #successfulblackwomen
StarEricka

StarEricka

302 likes

FOR SALE!!
2019 jeep g cheroke altitude Price $6500” Down payment $500 Runs and drives like new Engine and transmission in great shape Sunroof Heated seats Back up camera Private owner Clean title in hand Priced to sell You’re welcome for taking it to any mechanic #sellingcarsandtrucks #
Lemon587200521334

Lemon587200521334

40 likes

How to save money in car maintenance
To save money on car repairs, prioritize preventative maintenance like regular oil changes, checking tire pressure, and filter replacements, shop around for quotes from different mechanics, consider buying your own parts, and try to perform simple repairs yourself if you're able to; basically,
DoreensHusband

DoreensHusband

2 likes

Most people don’t realize that touch up paint is more than just buying a paint pen from the dealership. 🚗 This truck owner spent $40 on dealership touch up paint only to discover it didn’t even match his truck—and it was missing the clear coat needed for a proper repair. Another client with a bl
Amanda Buttons

Amanda Buttons

0 likes

Do you agree? #mechanic #bluecollar #mechanics #cars #dealershiplife
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

4 likes

Day in the life of a female car dealer @Milli Mac Motors 🚘 #serialentrepreneur #dayinmylife #successfulblackwomen #Viral #DITL
StarEricka

StarEricka

1 like

🚨 It’s going down. A woman brought her truck to Kia of Lake Charles to get it fixed—but she says she caught workers allegedly borrowing parts from her vehicle for other cars. 😳👀 By the time she discovered what was happening, she says her motor had been removed, even though the engine was working fi
user5565641389678

user5565641389678

0 likes

How to buy a car at a dealership! (My experience)🚗
I bought a 2018 Chevy Spark with 74,000 miles for $9,000! Went to test drive today and was not expecting to bring it home the same day!! My aunt went with me bc she had access to my fund money that was created when my dad passed. I don’t have access to it bc I’m not 21 yet (I’m 20). After we test d
Bre

Bre

10 likes

Come pick an online parts order at my Toyota dealership with me!..Order on our w
Come pick an online parts order at my Toyota dealership with me! . . Order on our website, free shipping over $75! . . #dealershiplife #toyota #partsdepartment #dealership #CarMaintenance
CourtesyToyota

CourtesyToyota

1 like

Mechanic life at the shop
#mechaniclife Working on the rear end of 98 Ford F-150. My co-worker loves being elbows deep. #mechanic #carrepairs
Scocca

Scocca

12 likes

Day in the life of a car dealership owner 🚘 #CarDealership #cardealer #dayinmylife #serialentrepreneur #vlog
StarEricka

StarEricka

3 likes

Come to the parts department at my Toyota dealership with me
Come to the parts department at my Toyota dealership with me! . . Order on our website, free shipping over $75! . . #dealershiplife #toyota #partsdepartment #dealership #CarMaintenance
CourtesyToyota

CourtesyToyota

0 likes

Working at a car dealership as a 19yr old
Follow me for my journey, posting on insta,tiktok,YouTube #cardealership #sales #explore
slywiththesales

slywiththesales

0 likes

Do a better job body shops
#get to know me #mechanic #technician #dealershiplife
Shane

Shane

1 like

Car Buying Secrets: Negotiate Like a PRO! Don't get ripped off at the dealership! Walk in confident and drive away with the best deal! #CarBuyingTips #NegotiationSkills #DealershipSecrets #SaveMoney #CarDeals #AutoFinance #SmartBuyer #NewCar #UsedCars #CarShopping
Ninadoesitall

Ninadoesitall

345 likes

An exterior view of the Kia Lake Charles dealership, with cars parked outside. A KPLC News overlay reports on a customer finding a mechanic borrowing parts, with weather information for Deridder.
A man walks towards the entrance of the Kia Lake Charles dealership. A KPLC News overlay reports on a customer finding a mechanic borrowing parts, with weather information for Grand Chenier.
A man in a red shirt gestures in what appears to be a service bay, with a car on a lift in the background. A KPLC News overlay shows MLB sports scores.
Lake Charles woman says Kia dealership used her car parts to fix another costumer’s vehicle
Dh1967

Dh1967

0 likes

A mobile auto care trailer for Johnny on the Go Auto Care, featuring their services like tune-ups, oil changes, and electrical work. It displays their contact number 321-466-5222 and website, emphasizing "car care, anywhere" in Orlando, FL.
Johnny on the Go mobile mechanic service
Location: “It’s car care, anywhere!” Based in Orlando, FL. #mobileautorepair #mobilemechanic
Johnny on the Go

Johnny on the Go

0 likes

Mr Never Mind

Mr Never Mind

0 likes

Sinister clean 🧼 Car detailing ATL
Anyone need their car interior cleansed 🙏🏽 dm me on IG: iiamsynn / sinceresservices ‼️
Dezarae Sincere

Dezarae Sincere

17 likes

Bought your dream truck but noticed paint chips, scratches, or paint loss after bringing it home? 👀 This Ford Raptor came in with existing rock chips and paint damage on the hood + mirror, and I brought it back to life ✨ I specialize in mobile automotive touch up paint repair for smaller damage
Amanda Buttons

Amanda Buttons

0 likes

I never thought I’d witness something like this while working at a car dealershi
What started as a completely normal day turned into one of the most unforgettable moments of my life. It changed the way I look at everyday situations and reminded me how quickly everything can change. I finally shared the full story in this video. Have you ever experienced a moment you’ll never
Travelandlivelife

Travelandlivelife

0 likes

Stop going to Dealerships
PicknBuild it — your car, your way. No credit check. No hassle. Get exactly what you want within your budget and save big. #picknbuild #dontgetplayed
picknbuild

picknbuild

0 likes

Most common TRICK by a car dealership
#gettoknowme #carbuyingtips #carbuyingadvise #carbuyinghelp #newcar
Lyndan C. 🚙That Car Guy

Lyndan C. 🚙That Car Guy

10 likes

time to get rid of my V6 and i need yall help #fyp #car #advice
SKII💡

SKII💡

0 likes

A woman takes a mirror selfie in a bathroom, with text overlay 'THINGS I LOVE ABOUT WORKING IN A DEALERSHIP', introducing the article's theme.
A clean desk setup features a computer monitor displaying a pink bow, keyboard, mouse, and office supplies, with text 'CUTE DESK'.
The interior of a car shows a steering wheel with a 'CAMARO' logo, with text 'I GET TO DRIVE WHATEVER CAR I WANT HOME', highlighting a perk.
Things I love about working in a dealership
#dealership #money #fitcheck #desktour To start off I am so grateful to even be given this opportunity to work at a dealership. And even more so bc this is my first job at a dealership. Cute desk- I love having my desk space. Having my own little office inside the dealership has rea
Sierra Nichole

Sierra Nichole

267 likes

What questions would you ask? #mechanic #mechaniclife #bluecollar #mechanictok #dealership
The Easy Way To Buy A Car

The Easy Way To Buy A Car

1 like

See more