Sweet cream coffee creamer recipe

I feel like it’s inhumane to change people coffee routine without giving them proper notice. And finding out it’s discontinued when you’re on the aisle looking for it should be criminal. #coffee #recipeideas #coffeerecipe #coffeelover

2025/1/15 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so I totally get the frustration of having your favorite coffee routine messed up! I swear, nothing is worse than heading to the store for your go-to sweet cream creamer, only to find out it's been discontinued. It felt like a personal attack on my morning! But instead of wallowing, I decided to take matters into my own hands and figure out how to make my own. And let me tell you, it's a game-changer! I stumbled upon this incredibly simple recipe for sweet cream creamer that only needs two ingredients. Yes, you read that right – just two! It's so much more affordable than buying those fancy bottles from the store, and you can customize it exactly to your taste preferences. Plus, you’ll never have to worry about running out or dealing with discontinued products again. This homemade sweetened cream for coffee is truly a lifesaver. My Go-To 2-Ingredient Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer Recipe Here's what you'll need: 1 cup heavy cream (or half-and-half for a slightly lighter version) 1/4 to 1/2 cup sweetened condensed milk (adjust to your sweetness preference) *Optional additions:* 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract (for a delicious vanilla half and half style creamer!) A tiny pinch of salt (enhances flavor) Instructions: In a jar or airtight container, combine the heavy cream and sweetened condensed milk. If using, add the vanilla extract and salt. Close the lid tightly and shake vigorously for about 30 seconds, or until the ingredients are well combined and slightly thickened. You can also whisk it in a bowl until smooth. Store your freshly made sweet cream creamer in the refrigerator for up to 1-2 weeks. That’s it! Seriously. It's so quick and easy, and the taste is absolutely divine. I promise, your coffee will thank you. Making it Your Own: Customizations & Copycat Secrets One of the best parts about making your own sweet cream creamer is how easily you can customize it. If you're a fan of a specific brand, like trying to achieve a copycat Chobani sweet cream creamer, you can experiment to get that perfect flavor profile. For a vanilla-forward taste, don't skimp on the vanilla extract – a good quality one makes all the difference. I sometimes even add a tiny bit of almond extract for an extra layer of complexity! You can also play with the sweetness level. If you prefer a less sweet coffee, start with just 1/4 cup of sweetened condensed milk and add more if needed. For those who like their coffee extra indulgent, you could even try a touch of maple syrup or a different flavored syrup instead of condensed milk, though the condensed milk gives it that classic creamy texture. I've heard people ask about using heavy cream powder for coffee, but for this sweet, rich creamer, liquid heavy cream is definitely the way to go for that authentic texture and flavor. It blends seamlessly and gives you that luxurious mouthfeel you crave in a good coffee creamer. Trust me, once you start making your own sweet cream creamer, you'll wonder why you ever bought it from the store. It's a simple pleasure that elevates my morning coffee routine every single day. Give it a try and transform your brew!

12 comments

✨Vero10🫶🏻's images
✨Vero10🫶🏻

I know how you feel I used to buy the big bottle of the international delight hazelnut coffee creamer that I would buy from Sam’s club they stopped selling it, so I just started buying sweetened condensed milk and adding a bottle of unsweetened hazelnut syrup mixed it together and put it in a glass bottle in the fridge but I never thought about doing it like this.

Andrea's images
Andrea

Was it delicious?

Related posts

A mason jar of homemade Italian sweet cream coffee creamer sits next to a mug of coffee, ready to be enjoyed. The image highlights the finished product of the recipe.
This image displays a clear mason jar, a bottle of vanilla extract, and a bottle of almond extract, illustrating the step of adding extracts after dissolving sugar in water for the creamer.
A carton of heavy whipping cream, a measuring cup of milk, and a mason jar with a yellowish liquid are shown, representing the step of adding cream and milk to the creamer mixture.
Italian Sweet Cream Coffee Creamer Recipe
I made my favorite store bought coffee creamer today, and you guessed it- I’ll never buy store bought again.😍 YOU NEED: 1 cup heavy cream 1 cup milk, I used whole milk 1/3 cup granulated sugar 1/3 cup water 1 tsp vanilla extract 1/2 tsp almond extract RECIPE: 1. Warm water til boiling and
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

128 likes

sweet cream coffee creamer✨
#coffeecreamer #sweetcream #homemade #recipe #coffee
OJT2021🍵🧋

OJT2021🍵🧋

43 likes

🌷 d.mitzi 🌷

🌷 d.mitzi 🌷

890 likes

Homemade coffee creamers!
Healthier options!!
Laura Curtis

Laura Curtis

645 likes

Starbucks sweet cream
How to make Starbucks vanilla sweet cream. It’s good for 2 days after making. #vanilla creamer #unfiltered #healthylifestyle2024 #starbucks #starbucksideas
Elyse Haley

Elyse Haley

8286 likes

How to make Italian Sweet Cream
#coffeecreamer #homemade 1 can sweetened condensed milk 1 3/4 cups half & half 3 teaspoons vanilla extract 1/4 teaspoon almond extract
Kym At Home

Kym At Home

33 likes

Homemade Vanilla Bean Coffee Creamer
It’s so simple to make your own creamer and this vanilla bean creamer just changed my coffee ☕✨ Smooth, rich, and perfectly sweet, it’s the easiest way to upgrade your cup without doing too much. Definitely staying in rotation. ✨ Save this for your next coffee moment. What you’ll need:
TheUrbanHomemakerMama

TheUrbanHomemakerMama

496 likes

Crème Brûlée Coffee Creamer Recipe☕️
I am alll about those vanilla/caramel vibe coffees and if you are too- I’ve got a recipe for you!😋☕️ YOU NEED: 1 12oz can evaporated milk 1/2 C brown sugar 1 1/2 C milk Vanilla extract, to taste RECIPE: 1. In a small pot bring brown sugar and evaporated milk to medium heat, stirring until su
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

1183 likes

Caramel Creamer ✨
Can’t make caramel sauce without making creamer as well 😋 Ingredients 🥣 1 cup milk 1 cup heavy cream 1/2 cup caramel sauce 3 tsp sweet condensed milk 1/4 tsp vanilla Pinch of salt Warm ingredients over heat approx 8-10 mins (DO NOT BOIL). #coffeeaesthetic #recipes #homemade
LexiLouWho

LexiLouWho

416 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer
Homemade Coffee Creamer! So easy to make and way better than store bought! 🫙1 can of sweetened condense milk 🫙Fill the rest of the jar with your choice of milk! 🫙Roughly 1tbs of vanilla (more or less whatever you prefer) 🫙A dash of cinnamon 🫙Put your lid on and shake! What’s your favorit
Jasmine F

Jasmine F

1147 likes

Sweet cream coffee creamer
😋⭐️Overall rating: 8/10
Daisy Martin

Daisy Martin

37 likes

HOMEMADE VANILLA CREAMER ☕️
Look what I did!!! 🙌 Homemade coffee creamer! 🥛☕ Gotta start somewhere, and this is my beginning! Who needs store-bought when you can whip it up yourself? 💪✨ 🥛 Homemade Coffee Creamer (Quart Size) Ingredients: 2 cups whole milk (or almond/oat milk for non-dairy) 2 cups heavy cream (or c
S_ABERNATHY

S_ABERNATHY

270 likes

Where are my coffee people at?
Andrea J

Andrea J

1191 likes

3 ingredients coffee creamer
#homemade #coffeecreamerrecipe #coffeeathome
Emily Drew

Emily Drew

2031 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer
I also added 1/2c water that I didn’t record! #coffeecreamerrecipes #coffeecreamer #homesteading #coffee
Cheyenne🌵

Cheyenne🌵

1038 likes

Home Made Sweetened Vanilla Coffee Creamer (32oz)
Thank me later!!! I purchased a 32oz jar (You can use any size jar that you would like, I wanted less sugar) I added: ✔️14oz of Sweetened Condensed milk ✔️18oz of unsweetened Coconut milk (If you want it sweeter you can just put the contents in a smaller jar) ✔️1/2 teaspoon of organic
Kyti Joi

Kyti Joi

1661 likes

Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer
Home Recipe Heavy Whipping Cream 4cups Brown Sugar 2cups Pinch of salt Vanilla 4tsp Cinnamon 4tsp Milk 4cups Bring everything to a slow boil and stir continuously. Let sit in the refrigerator till cool and place into glass jars. Enjoy! #homemadecoffeevibes #coffeecreamer #Reci
motherofcluckers10

motherofcluckers10

494 likes

HomemadeCoffee creamer
Brown sugar and cinnamon coffee creamer 10/10 Recipe: • 1 cup brown sugar • 1 cup water • 1 cup heavy whipping cream Warm this on the stove in a small saucepan over medium heat till brown sugar is dissolved Then add 1 tsp salt I personally added 2 tbsp of cinnamon and 2 tbsp of vani
Rach🍋

Rach🍋

2487 likes

Brown sugar & vanilla homemade creamer
#simplystephanie #homemade #recipes #creamer #coffee
SimplyStephanie

SimplyStephanie

532 likes

White Chocolate Mocha coffee syrup
I’ve been obsessed with making my own coffee syrups lately and couldn’t resist tryna copy this recipe. It comes out super sweet and thick! Perfect for coffee, ice creams & pastries as well :) #coffeeaesthetic #homemadecoffeecreamer #homemadecoffeesyrup #cooking #recipes
Ami Toro

Ami Toro

556 likes

homemade sweet cream creamer
simple ingredients #coffee #homemade #creamydeliciousness #athomebarista
heidi

heidi

12 likes

Homemade mocha coffee cream #coffeecreamer #homemade #homemadecoffeecreamer #coffeecreamrecipe #flavoredcreamer
WildHavenFarm

WildHavenFarm

136 likes

✨ Homemade Iced Caramel Macchiato ✨
Coffee shop vibes without leaving the house. 🤎 This one is creamy, sweet, and so easy to make! ☕ Recipe: • 2 tsp instant espresso • 10 ml vanilla syrup • 15 ml caramel sauce • 100 ml milk • 20 ml Chobani creamer, frothed Fill a glass with ice, mix the espresso with a little hot water, ad
NanaBannnana

NanaBannnana

583 likes

Homemade coffee Creamer
I used almond milk in mine but feel free to use your choice of milk! #homemade coffee #coffeecreamer #coffeerecipe #homemadecreamer #coffee
Emotionally Explained

Emotionally Explained

130 likes

Homemade Creamer is the best! ☕️💗
Skip the store-bought creamer and elevate your coffee game with this homemade Brown Sugar Vanilla Coffee Creamer! ☕✨ It’s rich, creamy, and made with simple ingredients you probably already have at home. Perfect for cozy mornings or an afternoon pick-me-up! 🏡💛 Save this recipe and thank me lat
airelmcgee

airelmcgee

1843 likes

Home made coffee creamers
_Coffey_Break_98_

_Coffey_Break_98_

525 likes

“Skip the Store, Make It At Home”
Homemade Coffee Creamer - 1 cup of heavy cream OR canned coconut milk (full-fat for a creamy texture) - 2 tablespoons of maple syrup or honey Optional flavoring: (French Vanilla - 1 tsp vanilla extract Hazelnut - 1 tbsp hazelnut extract Peppermint Mocha - 1 tsp peppermint extract Chocola
A N A B E L L E 🧺

A N A B E L L E 🧺

2079 likes

DIY Vanilla Sweet Cream Cold Foam 🤍☁️
The Starbucks fave, made right at home in just minutes! Perfect for topping iced lattes + cold brew. #vanillasweetcream #coldfoam #homemadecoffee #coffeeathome #icedcoffee
Felicia’s coffee & treats

Felicia’s coffee & treats

197 likes

Delicious 4 Ingredient Creamer
I've been loving making different things from scratch recently! One of the reasons is because I know whats in it, where buying different things from the store there's going to be a gazillion things in it and half the time you can't even read the word, where as making it at home you have
Adelina Norris

Adelina Norris

34 likes

A mason jar filled with s'more's coffee creamer on a speckled countertop, with text 'S'more's Coffee Creamer' and a 'SWIPE' arrow, indicating a recipe guide.
A pot containing sweetened condensed milk, cocoa powder, and ground cinnamon, with a spatula, illustrating the initial mixing step for the s'more's coffee creamer.
Half and half and vanilla extract being poured into a pot with the chocolate-cinnamon mixture, showing the next step in making the s'more's coffee creamer.
S’more’s Coffee Creamer Recipe
Fall is the season for s’mores, so naturally.. let’s add it in our coffee.☕️🥰 YOU NEED: 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk 2 Tbsp cocoa powder 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon 1 1/2 cups half and half or milk 1 tsp vanilla extract 1/2 cup mini marshmallows RECIPE: 1. In a pot over medium
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

1030 likes

✨homemade coffee creamer✨
I’m not okay with all the gross ingredients in store bought coffee creamer 🤢 so I started making our own with just 5 ingredients. -1 cup brown sugar -1 cup water -1/2 cup heavy cream -1/2 cup milk -1-2 tbsp vanilla extract heat the ingredients on the stove until the sugar is completely dis
Kayleigh

Kayleigh

14 likes

A hand holds a glass jar containing a white, frothy liquid, labeled "SWEET HOMEMADE COFFEE CREAMER." The creamer appears ready for use, with small bubbles on its surface.
Ingredients for homemade coffee creamer are displayed: a jug of raw cream, a bottle of vanilla extract, and a container of honey. An overlay lists the recipe: 1 cup raw cream, 2 tablespoons honey, and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract.
A small glass jar with a dark lid, containing a light brown liquid, sits next to an empty white coffee mug on a wooden surface. The image is captioned "ENJOY!".
Sweet homemade coffee creamer
☕️It’s so good and you don’t even have to waste more plastic or use harmful ingredients. Win win! Recipe 🐄 1 cup of cream (Raw cream from local dairy farm if possible!) 🍯 2 tablespoons of honey 🍨 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract ☕️ Mix together and put in delicious coffee! #recipe #f
Heather

Heather

4 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer 🌾
#homemadecoffeevibes #homemadecoffee
Gwin |momma

Gwin |momma

229 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer.Clean,Simple & Intentional
Making your own coffee creamer is so much easier than most people think and the best part? ✨ No chemicals ✨ No artificial flavors ✨ Just real, nourishing ingredients made with intention The base is always simple: 🥛 Milk 🥛 Half & half 🥛 Condensed milk From there, you can mix and matc
De Romero Wellness

De Romero Wellness

59 likes

Sweet Cream - Natural Bliss Coffee Creamer
4tsp of Nescafé Gold 2 oz of water 1 cup of whole milk 2-3 splashes of the Natural Bliss coffee creamer A dash of ground Cinnamon & Nutmeg & finally some Caramel drizzle on top! #athomecoffeerecipes #coffeeathome
Yoshimi Paloma

Yoshimi Paloma

3 likes

Coffee Creamers
Can’t wait to try all of these
Socalspitfire31

Socalspitfire31

102 likes

Irresistible salted caramel creamer recipe
Transform your coffee with this irresistible salted caramel creamer recipe☕️😎 Looking to level up your coffee game? Say goodbye to store-bought creamers make this homemade salted caramel creamer. That’s so easy and ridiculously delicious! Just a few simple ingredients and you’ll have the perfect
Stephanie

Stephanie

79 likes

Today’s sip: Frosted Sugar Cookie Bliss 🍪🤍✨ Creamy, sweet, and giving bakery-fresh vibes in every sip! Bonus points for reusing my Nescafé jar because cute and sustainable is always a win. ♻️🥰 Recipe: 🤎 Ice 🤎 6 oz brewed coffee (cooled) 🤎 3–4 tbsp International Delight Frosted Sugar Cookie C
Natasha Freeman

Natasha Freeman

273 likes

Vanilla Sweet Cream Cold Brew recipe for fall! ☕️🍂
Here is my go-to homemade Iced Vanilla Sweet Cream Cold Brew recipe for fall! ☕️🍂 Skipping the coffee shop drive-thru saves so much money, and making your own vanilla sweet cream at home is surprisingly simple. Grocery Ingredients: Coffee Base: Venetian Vanilla Ground Coffee + French Press S
Imanie Guajardo

Imanie Guajardo

13 likes

A vibrant pink strawberry lemonade slushie in a clear glass with a straw, ready to be enjoyed. The text overlay reads "PINK STRAWBERRY LEMONADE SLUSH."
A clear plastic container of fresh strawberries and a pink lemonade flavor drink packet, displayed as key ingredients for the slushie recipe.
A clear container filled with sliced fresh strawberries, prepared for blending. The text overlay indicates to cut strawberries and suggests freezing them for a thicker texture.
Blend & Go Strawberry Cream Slushie Recipe
This slushie is the perfect mix of sweet, tangy, and creamy—like a summer dessert in a cup. Ingredients • 2 cups strawberries • 1 cup cold water • 1 pink lemonade flavor drink packet • 2 cups ice • Splash of zero sugar sweet & creamy coffee creamer Instructions • Add strawberries
Karina

Karina

1509 likes

The easiest, best tasting and versatile homemade coffee creamer there is! I’m so picky about creamers and this one is chefs kiss! You can add so many things to change it up seasonally, too! Enjoy ☕️ #homestead #selfsufficient #canningandpreserving #coffee #wellness
Barefoot.mimosas

Barefoot.mimosas

334 likes

Brown Sugar Cinnamon Coffee Creamer
2 cup brown sugar, packed 2 cup water ground cinnamon salt 2 cup heavy cream vanilla extract #recipes #homemade #coffeecreamer #coffee #easyrecipe
Homesteadinbish

Homesteadinbish

30 likes

A glass jar of tiramisu coffee creamer sits on a kitchen counter next to a coffee mug and coffee maker, with text overlay 'Tiramisu Coffee Creamer' and 'swipe'.
Sweetened condensed milk is poured from a can into a saucepan containing half and half, illustrating the first step of combining ingredients over medium heat.
Espresso powder and cocoa powder are shown in a bowl with a small amount of warmed milk mixture, ready to be mixed until smooth as part of the recipe.
Tiramisu Coffee Creamer Recipe☕️
Who doesn’t love a good tiramisu?😋 This creamer brings all those rich, creamy flavors right into your morning cup of coffee.☕️ 🤍YOU NEED: 2 C half and half 1/2 C sweetened condensed milk 1 Tbsp instant espresso powder 1 Tbsp cocoa powder 1 tsp vanilla extract 1/2 tsp almond extract Pinch of
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

1206 likes

A jar of homemade coffee creamer sits on a kitchen counter, with the words "homemade coffee creamer" overlaid. The creamer is light-colored, and the jar has a gold lid. Kitchen utensils are visible in the background.
homemade coffee creamer
I jumped on the homemade coffee creamer bandwagon purely out of curiosity about a month ago and I am neverrrrrr turning back. It’s really good, quick to make, and elevates my home coffee. My recipe changes every time I make it, but right now these are the ingredients and measurements I’m using:
Kirsten

Kirsten

486 likes

Homemade Coffee Creamer✨
Make homemade sugar cookie coffee creamer with me ✨ #homemade coffee #coffeesyrup #coffeecreamer #coffeeaesthetic #homemadecreamer
CourtneyChris

CourtneyChris

1143 likes

Sugar Free Vanilla Sweet Cream
BLACKOUT 2025. COFFEE AT HOME! #blackout2025 #vanillasweetcream #coffeecreamerrecipes #coffeeathome #homemadecoffee
NicoleB

NicoleB

19 likes

Homemade coffee creamer 😋
Just three ingredients and it’s delicious! I use a 1 Quart Mason jar- ▫️Pour 1 can sweetened condensed milk into the 1 quart jar- I prefer the blue can but my store was out. ▫️Fill the rest of the mason jar up with milk- any type of milk will work. ▫️Pure vanilla extract- measured with your
Nicole

Nicole

1354 likes

Brown Sugar Coffee Creamer
This homemade, brown sugar creamer is the perfectly sweet addition to any coffee or tea for a delicious treat, anytime! Ingredients 2 cups half and half ½ cup brown sugar 1 tablespoon vanilla extract ¼ teaspoon cinnamon ¼ teaspoon sea salt fine Instructions 1. Add all ingredients to
Chaos Manager

Chaos Manager

50 likes

Homemade coffee creamer
Dunkin extra extra copycat recipe! #homemade coffee #homemade #dunkincoffee #copycatrecipes
Kristen Michael ☕️📚

Kristen Michael ☕️📚

47 likes

Homemade Vanilla Creamer
#recipes #relatable #homemadevanilla #french vanilla creamer #coffeeloverlifestyle
Spark of Grace

Spark of Grace

220 likes

how to make cold foam with no frother🍦 #coldfoam #homemadecoldfoam #waterbottlecoldfoam #athomedrinks #coffee #icedcoffee
Sage Lee

Sage Lee

174 likes

The BEST cookie butter iced coffee! 😍
This one is for all my cookie butter lovers! Simple coffee recipe that you can make ahead and have in your fridge. 1 cup of cold brew/ instant coffee 2 cups of water 1 cup of creamer - I’m using the Chobani Cookie Butter 1/2 of sugar - I used a 1/3 cup for this recipe because I thought
✨KMN - Blue Collar Wifey✨

✨KMN - Blue Collar Wifey✨

7 likes

Sweet + creamy coffee magic ✨
with Nescafe ice ☕️ #coffee #nescafe #icedcoffee #recipes #HomeCafe
Kyla 🤍

Kyla 🤍

1679 likes

Make your own coffee creamer!
Easy, tasty, vegan 📍Location: my kitchen #vegancoffeehacks #homemade coffee #homemadeproducts
susan

susan

39 likes

My Homemade Caramel Coffee Creamer
✨Recently i made a switch from standard premade coffee creamers that contained oils and artificial flavors to the “real cream” creamers which i loved way more. However, the better option didn’t have different flavors, was a little pricier, and despite being so good, it quickly got boring on days i
Momma Lex

Momma Lex

83 likes

See more