⭐️⭐️⭐️ “NYC” is overrated!

Coming from a native who has lived here alll her life, New York is sooo overrated and over hyped. The MTA has become one of the most dangerous ways to travel with shootings, people being pushed on the track, or simply just jumping into the track, homeless people put others in danger and innocent people getting sliced, 1/10 do not recommend.

When tourist say they’re coming to New York City I automatically know that they mean Times Square, no one visits the Bronx or even Brooklyn because what is the point? There are some good food spots and lounges but nothing out of the ordinary that you can’t find anywhere else.

The lights are cute but it’s pretty old at this point and all the characters dressed up ask you for money to take a picture even if you’re grown asf lol. But, this is coming from someone who is seeing the ins and outs of nyc and not just the glitz and glamour of it.

Advice to tourists: Please don’t stand in the middle of any side walk or walk slow, us locals are trying to get places and it’s already crowded enough, but good luck ! Everyone should visit at least one time. ☺️

#newyorkcity #newyorkcitylife #honestreview #travel #traveling #rating #nyctrip #nycguide #vacation #foryoupage

2024/3/9 Edited to

... Read moreI know my initial thoughts might sound harsh, but as someone who’s lived here forever, I’ve seen past the glitz and glamour that attracts so many. You see all those vibrant pictures of Times Square, just like the one with my 'Honest Review' and 'Overrated!' overlay, and think it’s the whole city. But trust me, there’s so much more to unpack when people ask, 'Is NYC overrated?' Let's talk about getting around. While I mentioned the MTA can be a real challenge, it's also a necessary evil for us locals. For tourists, it's often the quickest way to navigate the city, but here’s a tip from me: always be aware of your surroundings, especially during off-peak hours or late at night. Keep your valuable items secure and try to travel with a buddy if you're exploring after dark. It's not about fear, but smart city living. There are also ride-share apps, but nothing beats the speed of the subway when it's running smoothly. Now, about those 'overrated tourist attractions in New York City.' Times Square is definitely at the top of that list for me. Yes, the bright lights are iconic, and it's worth a quick look, but it quickly becomes overwhelming with crowds and characters constantly asking for money. If you want a truly memorable experience that feels more authentic, skip the endless souvenir shops and look for unique spots. Instead of just Times Square, consider a walk through Central Park, exploring the historic streets of Greenwich Village, or catching a lesser-known show off-Broadway. These places offer a deeper dive into the city's culture without the constant crush. Many visitors stick to Manhattan, and that's often where the 'overrated' feeling comes from. Queries like 'is East New York safe' or 'brooklyn dangerous' often pop up, and while I wouldn't recommend every corner of every borough for a first-time tourist, dismissing them entirely means missing out. The Bronx has incredible history and culture, and Brooklyn is a hub of vibrant neighborhoods. If you're looking to explore beyond the main tourist areas, do your research! Instead of 'areas to avoid NYC,' think about 'areas to discover responsibly.' For example, venture into areas like Williamsburg or DUMBO in Brooklyn for amazing food, art, and waterfront views. These are generally safe and offer a different, more local vibe without the same intense tourist crowds. Just remember, as with any major city, common sense and situational awareness are your best guides. And for food and lounges? While I said nothing's out of the ordinary, that's because the best spots aren't always in the guidebooks. The real magic of NYC lies in discovering those hidden gems in neighborhoods like Flushing for authentic Asian cuisine, or the diverse eateries in Jackson Heights. Don't be afraid to wander off the main avenues and let your nose guide you! You'll find incredible flavors and experiences that truly make NYC unique, far from the generic chain restaurants found in the super-touristy areas.

16 comments

See more comments

Related posts

Unpopular Opinion: NYC is overrated!
I live about an hour and a half from the city, and I’ve only been a handful of times. I haven’t been in at least 15 years! I can’t stand the traffic, more rude people, trying to figure out the subway, the crowds, over priced food/drinks, ALL OF IT! I love the nature of New York, the beautif
Saige | Toddler mom✨🪴❤️

Saige | Toddler mom✨🪴❤️

16 likes

New York City is incredibly overrated
Don’t get me wrong it’s cool, but it’s filthy, loud, expensive and 95% of people there are complete jerks. I’m not saying there’s nothing good about it, but it gets way too much credit. Thoughts? #AskLemon8
Melinda⭐️

Melinda⭐️

97 likes

AVOID THESE AREAS in NYC 🗽
Stay safe in NYC! ⚠️ 🌆NYC is generally safe for tourists, however there are some areas that should be avoided. These areas are known to have the highest crime rates, especially at night👇 • East New York: This is a neighborhood on the eastern edge in Brooklyn. It has a higher crime rate t
Sarah Close

Sarah Close

609 likes

NYC tourist traps to avoid
Traveling to New York for a first time? Avoid these tourist traps! Times Square Characters! Don’t take photos with the characters in Times Square if you’re not ready to cough up some cash! These photos are NOT free and they get quite aggressive if you try to avoid paying after taking a phot
Brooklyn Guide

Brooklyn Guide

2233 likes

I’m not going back
New York #newyork #nye @Delta Air Lines
Alley walley

Alley walley

1299 likes

is ambassadors clubhouse OVERRATED?! 😳 honest review incoming… #foodie #nyc #indianfood
Carrie Berk

Carrie Berk

1 like

A young woman smiles on a New York City street, with text asking "Overrated or Underrated? - NYC EDITION" and posing questions about Times Square and Broadway.
A hand holds a "The Phantom of the Opera" playbill inside a Broadway theater, with text stating Broadway Musicals are "UNDERRATED" and feature "super enjoyable, talented actors."
A nighttime view of Times Square, illuminated by numerous bright digital billboards, with text declaring it "OVERRATED" due to being "crowded, loud, dirty - a bunch of ads."
Overrated or Underrated ? - NYC
New York City is full of things to see and do, and sometimes it can be hard to decide which spots are worth the effort and $$ and which ones are just tourist traps better to steer clear of: Broadway Musicals: this is an activity that is definitely worth the hype. I’d consider it one of the mos
Lauren.e.albury

Lauren.e.albury

12 likes

Summit One Vanderbilt 📍NYC #tiktokgosummerfun #tiktokgo #nyc #summitone #nyclife
Lyndsie

Lyndsie

0 likes

A map of the US with several states highlighted, overlaid on a cityscape with buildings and a body of water. Text reads: "The Most Overrated and Underrated Places I've Been in the US 🇺🇸."
A scenic view of red rock mountains and green trees under a blue sky. Text identifies the location as "Sedona, AZ" and labels it "underrated," praising its beauty for outdoor enthusiasts.
A view from a car window showing a road surrounded by green trees. Text states that "New York" (both upstate and NYC) is "overrated," suggesting better and cheaper travel alternatives exist.
Underrated and Overrated Places in the US 🇺🇸
I know some people are going to be upset about my opinions on New York but it’s my opinion 🤷🏻‍♀️ Sedona : This is genuinely one of the most beautiful places I’ve been to in my life! I really like the outdoors, but even if you don’t there a bunch of cute shops located right in the center of town
🏖️🪩✈️

🏖️🪩✈️

113 likes

A woman stands in front of the Manhattan Bridge in New York City, with the text overlay "Don't fall for these scams in NY," serving as a cover image for travel tips.
A festive street scene, possibly Times Square, with a yellow taxi decoration and American flags, illustrating the warning about aggressive Disney characters demanding money.
The Manhattan Bridge is framed by brick buildings under a clear blue sky, accompanying a warning about pickpocketing and maintaining distance from strangers.
Don’t Fall For These Scams When In NY 🗽
If you’re traveling to New York soon, here are three common scams you should know about so you don’t fall for them. 1️⃣ Disney Characters In Time Square I’ve seen this in many cities, and in Times Square, you'll find several Disney characters asking to take pictures with you, then demandi
itsmarianavelez

itsmarianavelez

43 likes

A New York City subway platform at Utica Avenue station with red pillars and tiled floor. An overlay asks, "DISCUSSION: what is the WORST TRAIN in NYC," with "NYC" highlighted in orange.
What’s the WORST train in NYC?
A, G, D, 1, I feel like all New Yorkers and even visitors to New York have seen it ALL on the subway. Which one ticks you off the most? If my years in Brooklyn have taught me anything it’s that you can NEVER trust the A train, she will be late or she will be early but she will NEVER be on t
Jess 🧚

Jess 🧚

188 likes

New York City Is Not for Everyone
While New York offers an unparalleled array of experiences and opportunities, it’s important to recognize that it’s not the right fit for everyone. The fast pace, high cost of living, and crowded conditions can be daunting for many. If you thrive in a bustling environment and are prepared for the
By Esmirna

By Esmirna

43 likes

Pros and Cons of NYC
#lemon8contest #AskLemon8 These are the pros and cons of New York City! Some more pros and cons I haven’t listed, there are many good places to shop. The Public transportation is pricey. The weather is nice most of the time. It can be very noisy as someone who doesn’t like loud noises. Las
✝️Lily❤️

✝️Lily❤️

7 likes

Is NewYork worth it?
Location:New York #letschat ⭐️Overall rating: 8/10: busy season, super fun Comment your experience! don’t forget to like!
A

A

21 likes

A collage of four images showcasing various brunch dishes from different restaurants, with the overlay text 'OVERRATED BRUNCH SPOTS'. The dishes include a burger, fries, sushi, eggs benedict, avocado toast, and a croissant.
A close-up of a burger with fries and a side of ketchup, alongside a plate of sushi rolls drizzled with sauce, at The Smith, described as having 'mid brunch food'. A drink is also visible.
A table setting at L'Amico featuring two plates of brunch food, including eggs benedict-like dishes and an omelet, along with a coffee. The restaurant is described as having 'average brunch food in a nice ambience but very overpriced'.
overrated brunch spots in nyc
nyc brunch culture is intense, and while these spots aren’t bad, they don’t always live up to the hype or the long waits. here are a few that felt a little overrated for me: 1. the smith – always packed and loud, and while the food is solid, it’s pretty standard for the price. you’re mostly payi
nessie

nessie

55 likes

what is your unpopular nyc opinion?
nyc has something for everyone - or does it? i personally love discovering downtown as there are always events, cool spots, and amazing aesthetics. while i havent explored uptown as much (upper east and west sides), they seem a little more like midtown in terms of vibes - overcrowded and too in
brandiiimihajic

brandiiimihajic

4 likes

Is Central Park Really Worth the Hype?
Is Central Park really as amazing as everyone says? Sure, it's big and has some nice spots, but whenever I visit, it feels overcrowded and not that different from other urban parks. With so many other unique attractions in NYC, I'm starting to think Central Park is just a tourist trap. Am I
Ashley Jones

Ashley Jones

112 likes

I’m guilty of these NYC mistakes 🫠
🚈 Get familiar with transportation before you go The subway is definitely the best way to get around, but it can be a bit confusing if you’re not familiar with it. It’s best to research how to use and navigate it before you go so you’re not wasting time trying to figure it out when you could be
Sarah Close

Sarah Close

19 likes

A display of folded t-shirts on wooden shelves, featuring various graphic designs including 'GOLF', 'I CHROMATOPIA' with a mask, and 'AMERICA IS D POISON!' in different colors.
A person wearing blue jeans holds a yellow shopping bag with the black 'GOLF' logo on their lap, seen from a top-down perspective.
Several jackets in various colors and patterns, including pink, orange, and cream, hang on a clothing rack with 'GOLF' branded hangers and tags.
Overrated & Overpriced?
Just came back from the Tyler, the Creator’s store in SoHo NYC. Absolutely LOVED the vibes. But tbh everything in the store was so expensive. I bought a tote bag for $35. Well, YOLO😀 #lemon8diarychallenge #fyp #sohonyc #tylerthecreator #fashion
.

.

131 likes

TikTok ruined people’s idea of NYC
The NYC locals know and the NYC social media shows feel like two completely different places. What neighborhood actually represents REAL New York #nyc #gentrification #nyclife #ti3rranyc
Ti3rraTravels

Ti3rraTravels

0 likes

nyc is doomed #fyp #ranking #nyc #nycmayor
Idk

Idk

0 likes

An aerial view of the New York City skyline at sunset, featuring the prominent Empire State Building on the left and other skyscrapers. The sky transitions from blue to orange. Overlay text asks, "What's an overhyped city? And where should you go instead?" The Lemon8 logo is in the bottom left corner.
Overrated cities 🤔🌇
Is there a city you think gets too much hype for what it is? Where should others consider visiting instead? 👀✈️
Lemon8 Travel

Lemon8 Travel

66 likes

Fake NYC influencers are ruining the idea of NYC
NYC locals know! And the NYC social media shows feel like two completely different places #nyc #gentrification #nyclife #ti3rranyc
Ti3rraTravels

Ti3rraTravels

0 likes

Is NY really bad like they say❌?!
Hiii, I’m traveling to Manhattan soon. Anyone from NY can shed some light on things to do/ places to eat. •Vegan Restaurants, •Attractions …Also does NY really lack hospitality? I’m from LA so everyone embraces one another (random dancing with a stranger in the street🤭) #Lemon8Diary #le
Tia Lashaé

Tia Lashaé

10 likes

NYC is the worst state for dating
#datinginnyc
@ALITTLEBITOFEVERYTHING52

@ALITTLEBITOFEVERYTHING52

0 likes

OVER HYPED NYC RESTAURANTS
What are the most overrated NYC restaurants? The place where you can’t get a resy, or have to wait in line, only to think “that’s it??” When you finally go. Hit me up with you thoughts in the comments #nycfoodreview #nyc #nyceats #foodreview #food
High Low Feast

High Low Feast

3 likes

Tourist spots? Overrated 😏 Here are 3 must-visit NYC gems locals actually love: 🍸 The Red Pavilion – cocktails + AAPI culture 💃 Duane Park – dinner, jazz & burlesque 🌿 Brooklyn Botanic Garden – serenity + amazing café vibes #NYC #HiddenGemsNYC #NYCSpots #ExploreNYC #NYCLife
Natalia

Natalia

0 likes

An outdoor subway station with a train on the tracks, featuring text overlays asking 'WHAT IS THE SUBWAY?' and showing various subway line identifiers like 'DEFGJL' and '1234567'.
A grid displaying the letters and numbers of the NYC Subway lines, each within a colored circle, against a dark background.
An interior view of an NYC subway station, showing stairs, a platform, and a sign for 'City Hall' and the J and Z lines, with a person walking.
What is the worst subway in NYC?
Discussing what is the worst subway line in your opinion? #nycsubways
MR. THINKHEKNOWSITALLGURU

MR. THINKHEKNOWSITALLGURU

1 like

A collage of various Asian dishes from different restaurants, including dumplings, noodle soups, and gukbap, with the text overlay "OVERRATED ASIAN FOOD IN NYC."
A wooden table setting at Okdongsik featuring small metal plates of kimchi and a red sauce, with chopsticks and a cup, and text about NYC Asian food being overhyped.
A table at Nan Xiang Xiao Long Bao with a bowl of wontons in chili oil and a bowl of noodle soup, with a person in the background, and text about spots being overhyped.
nyc asian food that’s overrated
nyc has amazing asian food, but some spots are a little overrated — not bad by any means, just maybe not worth the hype or long lines. here are a few i’ve tried: 1. okdongsik($14–$18 per gukbap) – tiny space with long waits, and while the gukbap is decent and comforting, it doesn’t quite live up
nessie

nessie

16 likes

Two young women pose inside a New York City subway car, illustrating the "HARSH REALITY of being a commuter college student in nyc." The image captures the daily experience of navigating urban transportation.
A young woman takes a mirror selfie, with text overlay stating she spent almost "$250 on transportation this week and it's only tuesday..." This highlights the significant financial cost of commuting for a college student.
A young woman stands in a subway station with "SPRING" on the wall. The text overlay details her transportation expenses: "$133 unlimited metrocard" and "$111.13 lyfts," totaling her recent commuting costs.
harsh reality of being a nyc college commuter
(written last week) Let me preface that this is not everyone’s experience and I’ve had an especially interesting living situation compared to other NYC students. I’m 20 years old and I live with 2 random women in their 50s/60s, but that’s not the point of this. I just got back from spring break on
julie lui

julie lui

18 likes

What not to do in NYC
Storytime: one night in nyc, me & my friends noticed this person following us and saying some really scary, threatening stuff. It was late & the streets were empty, and we were genuinely terrified. Thankfully we got away safely, but it was such a wake-up call. This is your reminder to al
⋆˚࿔ Vale 𝜗𝜚˚⋆

⋆˚࿔ Vale 𝜗𝜚˚⋆

9 likes

Why I Hate-Love Living in NYC 🗽 Thoughts??💭
❤️Loving life in NYC at almost 30 comes with its unique perks and challenges. 👍Pros: Reasons I Love Living in New York: #1 . Career Opportunities: The city's a playground for professional growth, offering diverse job prospects. #2 .Cultural Diversity: NYC is a melting pot, bringing
CamilasCloset

CamilasCloset

4 likes

Why I’m Leaving NYC
I was born and raised in NYC and I used to think I would never leave. But as the years have gone on and I’ve experienced more, I’m realizing that I’m actually unhappy here and this is why: 1. It’s wayyyy too expensive: If you’ve ever been to NYC you know what I mean. I went to college in Georgia
Allie ♡

Allie ♡

57 likes

hot take: i never liked nyc
ok hear me out ive never been an nyc girly, it’s so overwhelming, SO GLAMORIZED and romanticized !! not saying it’s not a great place but just not for me, the food i do admit is AMAZING. i use avoid going there tbh but now i have to go every month and it’s definitely growing on me. here’
kimanna 🍒

kimanna 🍒

29 likes

Disappointed At The Pizza in New York?
#pizza #pizzalovers #nycpizza #nyc
Jas & Kam Food Reviews

Jas & Kam Food Reviews

1015 likes

NEW YORK Places I didn’t regret visiting ✨
• Remi43 Flower & Coffee 💕 This place is all about the atmosphere. It feels so refreshing to be surrounded by plants and birds! Yes, birds be flying there so if you’re scared of birds this is not the right place for you 🤪 • Funny Face Bakery 🧁 Such a beautiful bakery! The staff is
KK 💕

KK 💕

2900 likes

Overrated cities? 🤔🌇
Nah you just gotta have the heart & mind to have fun 🤠 had an amazing week 🥳 dressed up for a ball and cowboy glam themed mixerrrr. Ate with my friends and shared testimonies and what God’s been teaching us lately. Lost my phone 😂😂 got it back by the grace of God fr. #dallas #nyc
riamby

riamby

40 likes

Don’t do these things in NYC
Traveling to New York soon? Don’t make these common mistakes! Not wearing comfortable shoes! You will be walking FAR more than you realize even if you don’t plan on it! Make sure you wear shoes that won’t hurt your feet and that you can walk at least 10,000 steps in! Taking taxis everywher
Brooklyn Guide

Brooklyn Guide

45 likes

🗽What To AVOID in NYC🗽
New York City may be the ultimate adventure, but here are some “don’ts” for a better experience! 👇 1️⃣ Rushing into Times Square It’s iconic, but let’s be real—it's crowded and overwhelming! Check it out, snap your pic, and then escape to a cool rooftop nearby. 2️⃣ Falling for Tourist Tr
Julia

Julia

64 likes

NYC: Is it Paradise or Tourist Trap? ✨
#lemon8diarychallenge #lemon8challenge New York is undoubtedly one of the most iconic cities in the world, renowned for its towering skyscrapers, vibrant cultural scene, and bustling energy. However, beneath its glamorous facade lies a city grappling with the challenges of mass tourism.
Sseemaxx

Sseemaxx

12 likes

A collage of nine vibrant images showcasing various interactive art installations and colorful spaces in New York, including neon signs, illuminated floors, hanging decorations, and unique interiors, with the text 'Cool places in New York' overlaid.
A collage of six images featuring the HERO interactive art experience, displaying various rooms with blue and purple lighting, illuminated floors with spiky structures, cloud-like installations, starry ceilings, and a neon-lit hallway.
A collage of six images from the INTER_IAM museum, showing immersive art installations with blue geometric lights, a colorful floral archway, white hanging fabric, a purple projected flower, a striped mannequin, and a room with reflective surfaces and foliage.
Cool Things to do in New York 🗽
Here are some cool GEM spots for your NY backer list 💌 1) HERO 20-30 min walk though of interactive art. Great for photo ops. If you are an artist type you would like this, macarons and hot coco or coffee was a nice touch ✨ 2) INTER_IAM It’s so pretty inside!! Sooo many cool spots
KK 💕

KK 💕

8484 likes

A bustling aerial view of Times Square, New York City, featuring bright billboards, yellow taxis, and numerous pedestrians, with the title "Avoid These Times Square Restaurant Tourist Traps!" overlaid.
The exterior of the Hard Rock Cafe in Times Square, showing its iconic marquee and people walking past on the busy sidewalk, as listed as a restaurant to be cautious of.
The vibrant interior of a restaurant named "Stardust," featuring patrons seated at booths, a performer on a stage, multiple screens, and a disco ball, indicating a lively dining experience.
Avoid These Times Square Restaurant Tourist Traps!
Times Square is a must-visit in New York City, but not all dining options here offer value for money. To ensure a memorable culinary experience, be cautious of the following establishments: 1. Guy Fieri’s Chicken Guy: Located at 136 West 42nd St., this eatery has faced criticism for its
Emma Taylor

Emma Taylor

117 likes

NYC restaurant Week: Not Worth The Hype 🍽️💔
#nycrestaurantweek #lemon8foodguide #food #restaurantreview #nycfoodreview I Tried La Grande Boucherie with my brother. Due to allergies, couldn't opt for the $60 set dinner, so we ordered à la carte. Served tough bread, warmed on request. Started with *Les Escargots* -
Ellie K

Ellie K

24 likes

This isn’t really up for debate if you live in the Bronx don’t even @ me
#nyc #boroughs #ranking #newyorkcity #opinion
Milkies ❤️

Milkies ❤️

0 likes

Apartment hunting in NYC is not for the weak lol This should've been red flag #1 - if the realtor is THIS eager to finish working with an owner... he's not going to be an easy landlord to work with 🫠 #nyc #nycapartment #nycapartments #nycapartmentsearch #realtor #landlord #renter
Kate Lewis | K8NewYork

Kate Lewis | K8NewYork

3 likes

A promotional poster for "THE IMPACT NEW YORK" on VH1, featuring nine diverse cast members, mostly women, posing confidently in stylish attire against a backdrop of a city skyline at dusk. The title "THE IMPACT NEW YORK" is prominently displayed.
What are your Thoughts on The Impact NYC
I WANT YOUR OPINION 🍓 OPEN DISCUSSION HERE 😄😁 I want to know your thoughts and what do you think of the new show. 🤍 What's your opinion on the cast members? What's your opinion so far in the show? Did anyone watch this weeks episode? How are you feeling about certain situations? Do yo
Yana 💌

Yana 💌

47 likes

A tall, slender skyscraper, 432 Park Avenue, is shown from a low angle, framed by reflections and other buildings. A white hand-drawn circle highlights the building. Text overlay announces a $165M lawsuit over cracks and structural issues.
Are those just a rich person’s scam?
So, 432 Park Avenue in NYC that skinny, iconic condo (425m tall, celeb-filled, J.Lo once lived there) is making headlines. 96 owners just sued for $165M, claiming developers hid thousands of cracks, water leaks, rusting steel, and structural sway. Market’s tanking too. 2025 valuations down 37%,
Kaia

Kaia

3 likes

See more