McD’s Holiday Pie

So I have not been a personal fan of the McDonald’s apple pie since they changed from the deep-fried delicious crunchy version - to the healthy baked version.

However, I wanted to try the new holiday pie - and I am so glad that I did.

The texture reminds me of a slightly undercooked sugar cookie with a flavor hint of funfetti cake.

For anyone that likes their cookies, super soft and a little underdone - this is a must try!

#lemon8christmas #mcdonalds #mcdonaldspies #holidaypie #lemon8review

2023/12/20 Edited to

... Read moreOkay, so after getting my hands on that delightful McDonald's Holiday Pie, I just had to share more of my thoughts! You know how sometimes a seasonal item just hits different? This is definitely one of those times. When I first saw the familiar McCafé Pie box, I was already intrigued. It has that classic yellow grid design, but what really catches your eye are the vibrant, colorful sprinkles peeking out from the crust. And, of course, the little 'Caution HOT!' warning, which is always a good sign for a fresh, warm pie right out of the kitchen! The details on the packaging, down to the festive emojis, really set the mood. Taking that first bite of my McDonald's Holiday Pie was an experience in itself. The original article mentioned it, but I really want to emphasize the texture. It’s not just soft; it genuinely feels like a perfectly soft, undercooked sugar cookie. The crust itself, adorned with those festive sprinkles, holds a surprisingly creamy, soft, yellow filling. It's not a fruit filling like the apple pie; instead, it's a sweet, vanilla-like custard that perfectly complements the funfetti cake notes. The way the sprinkle-decorated crust gives way to that smooth interior, especially in a bitten McDonald's Holiday Pie, is just pure comfort. It’s a completely different vibe compared to the traditional baked apple pie. Speaking of the baked apple pie, I know many of us miss the deep-fried version, but the current baked one has its own charm. The baked apple pie has a more uniform, firmer crust and a warm, spiced apple filling. It’s comforting and classic, especially if you love that traditional apple pie taste. But the Holiday Pie? It’s pure whimsy. The sprinkle-decorated crust adds a playful crunch and extra sweetness that the apple pie doesn't have, making it a much sweeter, almost dessert-like experience rather than a fruit pastry. If you’re looking for a dessert that’s less about traditional fruit flavors and more about pure festive sweetness and a unique texture, this McD's Holiday Pie truly stands out. It's truly a different beast from the McCafé apple pie offering, carving its own special place in my heart! I often grab these kinds of treats when I'm out and about, and it's perfect for a quick snack on the go. Whether I’m rushing between holiday errands or just need a little pick-me-up, it fits right into the car cup holder – yes, sometimes even balanced on the car steering wheel for a quick photo op before devouring! The packaging is sturdy, making it easy to enjoy without a mess. Now, for those wondering about McDonald's Holiday Pie nutrition – let's be real, it's a holiday treat, not a health food! While I don't have the exact numbers, it's definitely something to enjoy in moderation as a sweet indulgence. Think of it as a festive reward. If you're curious about the specifics, McDonald's official website usually has all the detailed nutritional information available for their seasonal items, so you can check that out before you treat yourself. Overall, if you're a fan of soft-baked goods, funfetti flavors, and are looking for a break from the usual fruit pies, give the McDonald's Holiday Pie a try before it's gone. It's a delightful, unique treat that truly surprised me in the best way possible, and I think it might just surprise you too!

Related posts

Two finished McDonald's Holiday Pies, cut in half to show the yellow filling, topped with white icing and festive red and green sprinkles, on a wooden surface.
Ingredients for McDonald's Holiday Pies laid out on a wooden board, including pie crusts, cake mix, cream cheese, instant vanilla pudding, milk, vanilla, and sprinkles.
A white bowl containing the creamy yellow filling mixture for the holiday pies, with a container of red and green sprinkles beside it, illustrating steps 1 and 2 of the recipe.
McDonald’s Holiday Pies!
These copycat McDonald’s Holiday Pies just unlocked my childhood 🎁✨ #holidayrecipes #christmas #mcdonalds #baking #viral
Lex

Lex

585 likes

McDonald’s Holiday Pie at home 🏠 🥧🥰
For when your mom says you have holiday pies at home🥧🎄🤶🏽 Ingredients• ~Filling~ Pillsbury mini pie crust 1 (8oz) pkg cream cheese,softened 1/4 cup yellow cake mix,dry mix 1 cup milk 1 tsp vanilla ~Egg Wash~ 1 large egg 1 tbs water ~Glaze~ 1 cup powdered sugar 2-4 tb
hannmariek

hannmariek

21 likes

McRib is Back At Mcdonald’s! Ft. Holiday Pie
How Do Yall Feel About It? #mcdonalds #fastfood #fastfoodorder #foodies #mukbang
Jas & Kam Food Reviews

Jas & Kam Food Reviews

155 likes

A rectangular McDonald's holiday pie, topped with colorful sprinkles, rests on a dark wooden surface next to its dark brown McCafe PIE box. The box features a pie lattice design and the text 'McCafe PIE'. The phrase 'THEY'RE BACKKKKK' is overlaid on the image.
mcdonald’s holiday pies 🥰
#holiday #seasonal #mcdonalds
madi.batty98

madi.batty98

15 likes

Return of the McRib & Holiday Pie ❤️
#mcdonalds #mcribisback #holidaypie
Olivia Delgado

Olivia Delgado

74 likes

HOLIDAY PIES
#lemon8diarychallenge #holidayseason #mcdonalds
Staxxz🫧

Staxxz🫧

3 likes

A McDonald's Holiday Pie, light-colored with colorful sprinkles, sits in its open red and brown box. The red box features "HOLIDAY PIEEEE" text and a yellow smiley face. The brown base shows McDonald's copyright information.
Do you like this pie?
I honestly think it’s so good! I get it at least once during the season. I’m not a huge fan of McDonald’s so I usually get the kids meal if anything lol The little cheeseburgers are good! The holiday pie is basically just like vanilla custard inside and colorful sprinkles on top! I don’t ge
Brianna Diaz

Brianna Diaz

27 likes

It is good but.....
What's so holiday about this pie? To me, it tastes more like a fancy birthday cake. I do like it but I think it's a missed opportunity. They could do something really fun. Maybe a hot cocoa pie or they could scrap the pie and maybe do sugar cookies. Like McDonald's themed Christmas cook
Jessalyn

Jessalyn

2 likes

A McDonald's Holiday Pie with colorful sprinkles is prominently displayed, with another in its box. In the background, pancakes are being eaten from a black tray with a fork, next to a McDonald's knife and syrup.
Holiday pie from McDonald ✨
When it’s around thanksgiving I get excited because McDonalds restocks on their holiday pie. I like their apple pie but the holiday pie holds a special place in my heart. I remember trying them for the first time with my older brother. It’s a core memory I have with him. The holiday pie has this cr
Citlalli

Citlalli

2 likes

I wait 1 year for this holiday pie .
If you are a sweet lover you gonna love this 😘 #holidaypie #pie #macdonalds ⭐️Overall rating: 9/10: New York
shabrina🍁

shabrina🍁

21 likes

A hand holds a partially eaten strawberry cream pie, revealing the creamy white filling and red strawberry preserves inside. The image has text overlays indicating "Strawberry Cream Pie" and "McD's Dupe."
A white bowl contains ingredients for the pie filling: a block of cream cheese, a raw egg, vanilla extract, and sugar. The text overlay reads "Step 1: Filling" with a list of these ingredients.
Several rectangular pieces of pie dough are neatly arranged on a black baking mat with measurements. The text overlay says "Step 2: roll out dough" and describes cutting the dough into rectangles.
Strawberry Cream Pie Recipe- McDonald’s Dupe
A hubby request, once again. Lol these are literally identical and ya girl won’t have to worry if McD’s has them or not!😋 YOU NEED: Premade pie crust- I just made my own, if you’d like a recipe let me know! Strawberry preserves 8oz cream cheese, room temp. 1 egg tsp vanilla 3 Tbs sugar + so
Emerald.💗

Emerald.💗

378 likes

McDonald’s Holiday Pies 😋
Have you tried these? Do you like them? They are so delicious 😋 #mcdonalds #holidaypie #pie
Tenisha

Tenisha

4 likes

Holiday Pie sundae hack 🫶
Shout out to @Morgan Chomps for the yummy idea 💡 💌 Brand: McDonald's #holidaypie #icecream #foodhacks #mcdonalds
BIRDIE🐦

BIRDIE🐦

1 like

An opened McDonald's Oreo Pie in its brown box, revealing the dark-colored pie with white filling and cookie crumbles. The text overlay reads "Must Try! McDonald's Oreo Pie."
A close-up view of the McDonald's Oreo Pie, showing its dark, textured crust with white sprinkles and visible creamy filling inside the opened brown box.
The top of a McDonald's pie box, featuring the McCafé logo, the word "PIE," and a circular design. The box also indicates "PIE - BAKED" and "Caution HOT!"
Must Try! McDonald’s Oreo Pie
We tried the McDonald’s Oreo pie today and it didn’t disappoint! It is up there with the holiday pie in my opinion. Will definitely be purchasing again! What is your favorite McDonald’s desert? Let me know in the comments! @Lemon8 Food #foodoflemon8 #lemon8food #lemon8foodcoupon #letschat
AllisonBT

AllisonBT

4 likes

A McDonald's Holiday Pie, golden brown with colorful sprinkles, is shown partially out of its box on a brown paper bag. Text overlays announce 'MCDONALD'S HOLIDAY PIE IS BACK!' and 'AS OF NOV 15TH*'.
McDonald’s Holiday Pie is Back!
It’s beginning to feel a lot more like Christmas! Especially now that all of the holiday favorites are making their way back to the restaurants. Besides the very classic peppermint mocha flavor that I love so much. My other favorite is the Holiday Pie from McDonald’s. Back when I used to work a
H.Bar

H.Bar

18 likes

A McDonald's Holiday Pie, topped with colorful sprinkles, rests in its brown cardboard box on a striped blue and white surface. Festive text overlays like "MCDONALD'S Merry Merry HOLIDAY PIE Merry Merry" and heart emojis are visible, along with the Lemon8 username.
The only time I go to McDonald’s willingly
I absolutely love their holiday pies. They are delicious!! It’s basically just vanilla custard inside and a crust with festive sprinkles. I’m not sure if you can still get them unfortunately. My brother wanted McDonald’s on Monday so we went and no more pies ☹️ they said we have apple though 🤨 and
Brianna Diaz

Brianna Diaz

2 likes

Strawberry Crème Pie McDonalds Copycat
The best copycat recipe! #strawberrycremepies #strawberrypie #mcdonalds Ingredients 15 ounces refrigerated pie crust 425 grams (1 package) 2 cups hulled and chopped strawberries 334 grams, fresh or frozen 8 ounces low-fat cream cheese 227 grams, room temperature (1 brick) 1 large egg 50
Tambria | TTS

Tambria | TTS

13 likes

Pumpkin & Creme Pie 🥧
#falltreats #mcdonalds #pumpkinpie #fallfeelings #dessert ⭐️Overall rating: 5/10
Love Lynn

Love Lynn

5 likes

It’s back…
Had my first holiday pie of the season! #mcdonalds #holidaypie #sogood #treat
Jess

Jess

7 likes

Mcdonalds pies
Does anyone just ever crave a Mcdonalds pie!!! #pies
🦋PanicButton🦋Heidi

🦋PanicButton🦋Heidi

0 likes

McDonald’s Holiday Pie
Ingredients ▢ 4 9- inch uncooked pie crusts ▢ 1 (8 oz) package cream cheese, softened ▢ 1 (3.4 oz) package instant vanilla pudding ▢ ¼ cup yellow or white cake mix, dry mix ▢ 1 cup milk ▢ 1 teaspoon vanilla Optional Egg Wash: ▢ 1 large egg ▢ 1 tablespoon water Glaze: ▢ 1 cup powdered
Emilia St Jean

Emilia St Jean

1 like

A McDonald's McCafé pie, golden brown with a visible red strawberry filling, is partially pulled out of its brown cardboard box on a wooden table. The box displays "McCafé" and "PIE" along with a "Caution HOT!" warning.
Strawberry cream pie from McDonald’s???
These are so delicious and flavorful, I lowkey just wanted the pie just with the cream but still it tasted amazing!! #cute and delicious #so good #sweet #Lemon8Diary
🎧🗺️👙

🎧🗺️👙

4 likes

A McDonald's McCafe Oreo Pie is shown, partially removed from its brown packaging. The dark brown pie features white sprinkles and a visible creamy filling. The image includes a 'Caution HOT!' warning on the box and a 3/5 star rating.
McDonald’s Oreo Pie
It was okay 💁🏿‍♀️ #hellolemon8 #sweettreats #mcdonalds #cookiesandcream #oreos
🐆PrettyRe🐆

🐆PrettyRe🐆

15 likes

McDonald's Cookies N’ Creme Pie
⭐️Overall rating: 7/10: #foodie #macca
RICKY EATS

RICKY EATS

1 like

Blueberry & creme pie 🫐🥧
#mcdonalds #blueberrypie #tasty #dessert #foodblog Overall rating: 5/10
Love Lynn

Love Lynn

3 likes

A hand holds a McDonald's McCafe pie box with a "Caution HOT!" warning. A dark-colored Oreo pie, topped with white sprinkles, is being pulled out of the box. The image has an overlay text that reads "McDonald's Oreo Pie".
McDonald's Oreo Pie: Would You Try?
⭐️Overall rating: 3.5/5: Tasty but Could've Been Better Would you try? What's better? Oreo or apple pie? (McDonald's style of course) #Lemon8Diary #lemon8challenge #foodorder #FoodOfTheDay #letseat
Lauren|Career Girl

Lauren|Career Girl

5 likes

McDonald's holiday pie original recipe 🎀🩷🎁🎄🌿🎀🥧🥧🍰
Here's a recipe for McDonald's Holiday Pie: ## Ingredients: - 4 (9-inch) uncooked pie crusts - 1 (8 oz) package cream cheese, softened - 1 (3.4 oz) package instant vanilla pudding - 1/4 cup yellow or white cake mix - 1 cup milk - 1 teaspoon vanilla extract - Optional egg wash (1 e
Tammy Creation's Above

Tammy Creation's Above

5 likes

#McDonalds
Brie Simone

Brie Simone

0 likes

A festive Christmas pie features a large Christmas tree cutout in the center, revealing a vibrant strawberry filling. The pie crust is adorned with small star cutouts around the edge and on the tree design.
A golden-brown Christmas tree-shaped pastry, dusted with powdered sugar, sits on a dark slate board. It features a star on top and visible layers, with blueberries and a red berry beside it.
A festive pie features a top crust with a Christmas tree design formed by numerous small star cutouts, revealing a red berry filling. The pie's edge is also decorated with star-shaped crust pieces.
Christmas pies 🥧
Christmas pie inspo I saw via Facebook, and had to share it with you all!! #christmaspie #pieinspo #pie #holidayrecipes #recipeideas #HOLIDAY #holidaydessert #pies #christmas #happyholidays
Bridgetxo2

Bridgetxo2

154 likes

McDonald’s Holiday Pie
#Mcdonald #icedcoffee #icedlatte #coffeerecipe #latterecipe
Millionaiire Dee

Millionaiire Dee

10 likes

#Mcdonalds
Jeff531

Jeff531

5 likes

Copycat ORIGINAL McDonalds Apple Pie
McDonald's Original Fried Apple Pies Ingredients Apple Filling: * 2 large tart apples, peeled and diced * 2 tbsp butter * 1/3 cup brown sugar * ½ tsp cinnamon * ½ tsp cornstarch + 1 tbsp water * Egg for sealing Dough Options: * Homemade: Mix 1 ¼ cups flour, ½ tsp salt, and ½ cup col
Nev Brooks

Nev Brooks

1275 likes

McDonald's Holiday Pie Sundae Hack
#mcdonaldssecrets #Mcdonald #icecream #foodhacks
BIRDIE🐦

BIRDIE🐦

0 likes

A golden-brown apple pie with a lattice crust, revealing the apple filling, rests on a brown paper napkin. The pie is positioned on a speckled grey countertop, highlighting its warm, baked appearance.
McDonald’s Apple pies are hit or miss
This perfect apple pie from McDonald’s 🍎🥧 #pastries #desserts
Eris

Eris

5 likes

Cookies & CreamPie
I tried the new cookies & Cream pie. Am I the only one don’t like it? Or yall haven’t tried it yet? What are yall thoughts about this? #cookies 🍪 #mcdonalds #fyp #embracevulnerability
Courtney

Courtney

10 likes

Pumpkin Cream Pie de McDonald’s .
El Pumpkin Cream Pie de McDonald's es el nuevo postre de temporada que está causando furor, y en este video te muestro mi experiencia probándolo. Desde el primer bocado hasta el último, te comparto mi opinión honesta sobre su sabor, textura y si realmente vale la pena pedirlo. ¿Será que McDonal
QUEHAYPA'COMER

QUEHAYPA'COMER

1 like

A McDonald's late-night meal spread on a light surface, featuring a box of 10 chicken nuggets with sweet and sour sauce, a cheeseburger, fries, a red frozen drink, a dark soda, and two McCafé pies (one apple, one other flavor).
McDonald’s
Late Night Snack lol 🤩🤣🤤🥳 @mcdonalds - 2 cheeseburgers with Larger Coke and Fries - Strawberry & Cream Pie - Apple Pie - 10 Piece Nugget with Sweet & Sour Sauce - Wild Cherry Frozen drink #mcdonalds #latenightsnack #yummy #hitthespot #good food
Angela

Angela

8 likes

Been doing this since middle school 🥰 @McDonald’s #mcdonalds #mcdonaldssecrets #mcdonaldshacks #applepie #mcdonaldsapplepie
Eshaa

Eshaa

228 likes

apple pie McDonald's
pirate0155

pirate0155

1 like

i tried the holiday grinch meal @ mcdonalds! 🎄
Mcdonalds finally has something for us in the USA! I tried out the new Grinch Meal at McDonald’s and the grinch salt mcshaker fries are actually so good and super dill pickle flavored. It’s really fun to mix and shake them up. If you’re grabbing a quick holiday treat, this one’s worth trying. Plus
Myra 💞

Myra 💞

43 likes

Mini Holiday Pies!
#pumpkinpie #applepie #thanksgivingdesserts #thanksgivingrecipes #fyp Find the full recipes for pumpkin pie, apple pie, and homemade pie crust on my page!
Cookiemnstr555

Cookiemnstr555

47 likes

Md Donald’s Strawberry Pie
#mcdonalds #pie #DELICIOUS #foodrecommendations #dessert
Tony's View

Tony's View

1 like

McDonald's Apple Pie
⭐️Overall rating: 7 /10 #foodie #pie
RICKY EATS

RICKY EATS

1 like

A full Edwards Chocolate Creme Pie with whipped cream and chocolate toppings, next to its product box on a countertop. The box highlights 'FRESH BAKED COOKIE CRUST' and 'REAL CHOCOLATE'.
Who needs to bake when you can have a creme pie.
Ladylibra_Uniqueone

Ladylibra_Uniqueone

32 likes

Pancakes, Choir, and McDonald’s — A Mom’s Holiday
Vlogmas Day 4 🎄 Pancakes, choir, McD’s… Mom life in a nutshell! 🤍 #Vlogmas2025 #MomLife #FamilyVibes #HolidayChaos #RealMomMoments
BrittanyB

BrittanyB

3 likes

McDonald’s holiday meal 2025
Your a mean one Mr.Grinch. How cutesy.💚 #mcdonalds #holidays #grinch #christmas #Lemon8
Babygirl

Babygirl

7 likes

A hand holds a brown cardboard box from which a pie is partially emerging. The pie features a golden-brown crust filled with a dark, fruit-like mixture and creamy white streaks. The box displays a 'Caution HOT!' warning.
McDonald’s limited pie
If you’re in the mood for not that sweet pie then try McDonald’s Blueberry & Crème Pie ! Overall rating: /10: 5/10 #mcdonalds #mcdonaldsbreakfast #McDonald ’s 📍Location:humble, tx
jerome86

jerome86

7 likes

An assortment of eight different holiday-inspired spice and finishing sugar containers. These seasonal flavorings include various sweet and dessert-like options, designed for festive baking and culinary uses. The image highlights the beginning of the holiday season.
New Holiday Flavors 🤌✨
Every year these come out and it’s the start of the holiday season. 😘 What would you use them for? #food #foodie #HOLIDAY #HolidaySharing
Care-w/Natasha

Care-w/Natasha

5 likes

holiday pie 🥧🎄
made a split pie, half pumpkin, and half apple pie 🥧 😋 #pieseason #holidaypie #pie #applepie #pumpkinpie
Karebearbake

Karebearbake

4 likes

For McDonald’s codes with out having to pay for food!!! Do this up to like 5 times a day you can do them all at once I just found out!
Mommas❤️👩‍👦‍👦👼🏻

Mommas❤️👩‍👦‍👦👼🏻

1 like

A graphic explaining how to request free McDonald's Monopoly codes, stating that users can get 10 free codes daily by requesting 2 codes up to 5 times per day via email, without purchasing anything.
Score Free McD’s Monopoly Codes!
Guess What? Did you know? 🍟 You don’t have to buy a thing! Get up to 10 FREE McDonald’s Monopoly codes daily — just by requesting them at amoe.playatmcd.com. 🎯 I’m playing every day now — who’s joining me? ***Second photo is what I did today for proof! 🙂‍↔️ #Lemon8 #McDonaldsMonopoly #Mono
cichris

cichris

24 likes

A visual guide showing how to get free McDonald's with no purchase needed, featuring drinks, fries, and a list of app exclusive free food deals like sandwiches, fries, and nuggets, all expiring in November 2025.
A McDonald's Big Mac and drink, with text explaining to use free daily Monopoly spins for freebies, allowing 10 entries daily (5 times with 2 spins each).
A McDonald's Big Mac with an arrow pointing to the Monopoly game's Alternate Method of Entry (AMOE) website, detailing instructions for requesting a game code via email for free spins.
FREE MCDONALDS 🍔🍔
Here’s how to get FREE MCDONALDS: 💥 Go to the McDonald’s Monopoly site and claim your free daily spins 🎡 You’ll get 5 spins per day, and each one lets you spin twice, that’s 10 total chances to win 🍔 I’ve been winning almost every time! ⏰ The rewards don’t expire until next month 💸 No purch
Tyler

Tyler

1898 likes

McDonald’s pumpkin x cheesecake pie 😋
It taste more like sweet potato Either way it’s #sogood #mcdonalds #pie #creamcheese #pumpkin filling
passion

passion

3 likes

Holiday Coconut Pie Perfection
A little slice of tropical magic for the holiday season. 🥥❄️ This coconut pie is creamy, sweet, and the perfect break from all the pumpkin and pecan. It’s one of those desserts that disappears fast at Thanksgiving and somehow tastes even better at Christmas. If you’re looking for a new holiday favo
Miranda Baker

Miranda Baker

5 likes

McDonald’s creampies
Meechie Banks

Meechie Banks

0 likes

An unbaked pie in a crust, filled with a vibrant red and light-colored mixture of raspberries and apple pie filling, with the text 'EASY CHRISTMAS PIE' overlaid.
A collection of ingredients on a stovetop, including a bag of red raspberries, two cans of apple pie filling, and a box of pie crusts, with the text 'you'll need :' overlaid.
A clear glass bowl containing a mixed filling of red raspberries and light-colored apple pie pieces, with the text 'mix 1/2 the bag of raspberries and both cans of apple pie filling' overlaid.
EASY CHRISTMAS PIE 🥧❤️
although I like to make pies from scratch, this is a really easy and quick way to do it and it is all the same deliciousness. Apple is such a classic pie filling, but the raspberry really elevates it and gives it a Christmas vibe. It’s so simple. You have to try it ! #christmas #christmasrec
lindsay🌼

lindsay🌼

131 likes

See more