POV: You think you ruined your sourdough.

2/12 Edited to

... Read moreStarting a sourdough starter for the first time can feel like a rollercoaster, especially when the initial days seem discouraging. I remember the first time I tried it myself, noticing bubbles appear rapidly on Day 1, which made me excited. However, by Day 2, the starter looked dry and inactive, making me wonder if I had ruined it. It’s important to understand that different starters behave uniquely depending on factors like temperature, flour type, and feeding schedule. One key point I learned is not to give up early. Feeding your starter regularly and transferring it to fresh, clean jars can dramatically improve its health. For example, transferring to a new jar on Day 5 gave my starter a boost, showing increased activity just a few hours later. It’s also helpful to follow a consistent feeding ratio, such as 1:1:1 (starter:flour:water), to keep the yeast and bacteria balanced. Trusting the process means accepting some ups and downs while giving your starter time to develop naturally. Even if it looks less active or changes texture, it might still be alive and preparing to flourish. Observing signs like bubbles, a pleasant sour smell, and rising after feeding are good indicators of readiness. In addition, consulting online tools like ChatGPT or sourdough forums can provide reassurance and useful advice along the way. Remember, sourdough baking is as much an art as a science, and patience will reward you with delicious bread made from your very own starter. Don’t be discouraged by early doubts—day 6 can bring a joyful surprise with a bubbly, active starter ready to bake!

Related posts

forgot the salt… and accidentally created a whole new starter instead of a loaf 😭 I really thought I ruined everything. Sourdough will humble you FAST lol. #s #sourdough s #sourdoughfail b #bakingmistakes s #sourdoughstarter homebaker
Zoë101

Zoë101

7 likes

Sourdough fails 😭😭
#sourdoughliving #sourdoughlife #sourdoughfeeding
Sopfia the first

Sopfia the first

29 likes

Sourdough starter killers!
Have you ever seen these issues with your sourdough starter? Let me know in the comments! #sourdoughstarter #sourdough #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughbeginner #sourdoughdiscard
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

572 likes

Okay but never againnn she was gummyyy
livinwiththelances

livinwiththelances

125 likes

If your sourdough starter looks like this….
Throw it out! #sourdoughbeginner #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughstarter #sourdough #sourdoughbaking
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

70 likes

Overproofed Sourdough
This video is about more than just overproofed sourdough, it’s about overcoming mistakes. Slowly moving all of my videos over from TT. This one had 2.1 million views as of 01/18/25. #sourdoughproofing #sourdoughfail #sourdoughbeginner #sourdough
The Wandering Weavers

The Wandering Weavers

1768 likes

Avoid These 5 Common Sourdough Mistakes
When I first started making sourdough, I made every single one of these mistakes! Here's what I learned: 1. Using inactive starter: Even if it looks bubbly, your starter needs to be at its peak rise for best results. 2. Skipping stretch and folds: This step is crucial for building gluten stru
Camille Bakes

Camille Bakes

80 likes

A hand holds a freshly baked, scored sourdough loaf with a golden crust. The background features a brick wall and a framed painting. Overlay text reads: "Stupid Sourdough Mistakes I've made so you don't have to!"
A light-colored proofing basket (banneton) contains a linen liner and a red spatula. Overlay text advises new sourdough bakers to get a dehydrated starter or one from a friend for a strong start.
A baked sourdough loaf rests on parchment paper in a kitchen setting. Overlay text describes a mistake: washing hands with strong-scented soap, which made the bread taste like a candle.
Stupid Sourdough Mistakes I’ve Made
If you've made a dumb sourdough mistake, odds are l've probably made it too! Sourdough really is a journey. #sourdough #breadtok #sourdoughforbeginners 💡Tips for beginners: get an established starter 📝 Reflect on mistakes: don't use strong scented soap when handling dough
Free State Flourworks 🌾

Free State Flourworks 🌾

59 likes

Sourdough Fail
Sourdough will really make you feel like a professional chef one day and then completely humble you the next 💀 #sourdoughfail #sourdough #bakingfail #relatable #sourdoughstarter
SimplyJustinEats

SimplyJustinEats

0 likes

Sourdough Horror Stories!! #sourdough #breadtok #baking #SourdoughBaking
Kristin

Kristin

1 like

Let me help you revive your sourdough starter 🥰🫶
Starter looking rough? No judgment. No stress. Just real help to get her back on track. Follow me for chill, zero-BS sourdough tips 🍞 #sourdoughstarter #starterrescue #breadthatbites #tattooedbaker #feralbaking
Tatted & Toasty

Tatted & Toasty

7 likes

Sourdough is bad
#sourdough #sourdoughbread #bread
Yankeegirlgonecountry

Yankeegirlgonecountry

3 likes

Sourdough fail
I’ve done everything short of reading her bedtime stories 🫠 #sourdough #sourdoughstarter #homebaking #breadtok #bakingfail
Sarina Agarwal

Sarina Agarwal

50 likes

Rough day in the bakery 🤦🏾‍♀️ #sourdoughfails #sourdoughtok #sourdoughbread #sourdough #breadtok
Zoë101

Zoë101

4 likes

Day 4: EPIC FAIL… What Went Wrong?! 😩
Day 4: EPIC FAIL… What Went Wrong?! 😩 Well… that didn’t go as planned. 🫠 My sourdough starter didn’t make it, and I have no idea why! If you’ve been through this before, drop some advice in the comments—what could’ve gone wrong? But don’t worry, I’m not giving up! I’m determined to start agai
Preeti’s Eats

Preeti’s Eats

3 likes

A clear glass jar containing sourdough starter sits on a patterned surface by a window. Overlay text reads "HOW TO FIX YOUR SOURDOUGH STARTER SWIPE," indicating a guide.
A close-up of a bubbly sourdough starter in a glass jar. Overlay text advises, "Make sure you are not over feeding or under feeding" and "Feeds should be 1:1:1 ratio."
A sourdough starter is being stirred with a blue spatula, showing its texture. Text advises checking temperature (around 77 degrees) and changing flour, suggesting all-purpose and whole wheat for a boost.
How to fix your sourdough starter
Is your sourdough starter not rising? Is it only rising a little and not actually doubling in size? Please read this! It took me 5 weeks to get my starter established and very active! It took 3 weeks for it to even start rising. When it would rise, it would only rise slightly, and that's it.
BlissfulCreationzz

BlissfulCreationzz

5 likes

Sourdough fail?
When you think this was a fail but it actually turned out to be so delicious. #sourdoughfail #sourdough #bread #sourdoughbread
📚 Mylah 📚

📚 Mylah 📚

1 like

Why Your Sourdough Didn’t Rise (And How to Fix It)
If your sourdough turned out flat, dense, or gummy… it’s almost always a fermentation issue. Sourdough rises from wild yeast producing gas during fermentation — but that process is sensitive to a few key things: • Starter strength • Dough temperature • Fermentation time • Flour quality
Camille Bakes

Camille Bakes

14 likes

How to dehydrate your starter
Dehydrating your sourdough starter is a must! If you ever use up all your starter or it goes bad, having a backup means you won’t have to start from scratch. The process is super simple: 1. Grab some parchment paper or a nonstick baking mat. 2. Spread a thin layer of active sourdough start
stitches.n.sprouts

stitches.n.sprouts

26 likes

I was tired of cleaning sourdough starter
This hack has changed my life. I was so tired of cleaning my sourdough starter out of my glass containers and worried about the starter messing up my pipes. I do this sourdough trick to make my life easier and now I am able to just put it in the dishwasher! #sourdoughlife #sourdough #sourdough
Nicole

Nicole

16 likes

🛑STOP🛑 shaping your sourdough bread like this
Featured in this video is what I refer to as a “gentle shape”. You can use a gentle shape on a strong dough that has been well-fermented, which allows the gas to hold the dough tall and explode the loaf beautifully in the oven. I use this technique on doughs of all hydrations. True tartine-style
Caitlin Vincent

Caitlin Vincent

93 likes

Sourdough Mistakes
For those who missed it; I forgot to mix my starter and water together before adding the flour. Mistakes happen, but the dough mixed up really nice. Updates to come. I’m making Chocolate Chip loaves out of this. #doughrecipe #sourdoughrecipe #sourdoughbeginner #sourdough #sourdoughmistake
Jayqwalinn

Jayqwalinn

108 likes

Issues with your sourdough starter?
If you want to skip the process and start baking with a strong, active sourdough starter, ours is ready to go — and the reviews have honestly been blowing my mind. 💛 (Link in bio) If your sourdough starter seems weak or unhealthy, here’s what to look for 👇 🍼 Young Starter (under 3 months) •
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

70 likes

Baking over-proofed sourdough
Always bake the over-proofed sourdough! I was out at an event longer than I expected and my sourdough was slightly over-proofed. I baked it anyway and I’m so glad I did. She still tastes just as good 🤤 #sourdoughbread #sourdoughtips
danielle_morabito

danielle_morabito

14 likes

Has your sourdough starter peaked?
How to Tell if Your Starter is at Peak 1. Feed When Hungry • Use any ratio, but a heavy feed (like 1:3:3 or higher) makes it easier to test. 2. Watch the Rise • When your starter doubles, stir it down. • Wait and see if it grows again. 3. Interpret the Results
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

3350 likes

A round, golden-brown sourdough loaf with decorative scoring on its floured crust, resting in parchment paper. A wooden skewer is inserted into the side.
failed sourdough
I'll never stop until I perfect this bread 😂 #sourdoughfail #sourdoughjourney #sourdough #homemade sourdough bread
Tyra

Tyra

1 like

Sourdough fail
RIP Mamie Van ‘Dough’ran 😭🍞 #sourdough #sourdoughstarter
Ashlyn Hope

Ashlyn Hope

4 likes

Sourdough starter myths!
Don’t do any of these crazy tends! #sourdoughstarter #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdough #sourdoughlife #sourdoughbaking
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

393 likes

Sourdough Accidents
This week I accidentally left my sourdough in the fridge for 24 hours. 👀(12 hours more than I usually let cold proof). To my surprise it ended up in the fluffiest sourdough I’ve ever made. 👌🏼 Sometimes accidents result in amazing things! 🤭 Florida
Gabriela Marsh

Gabriela Marsh

0 likes

4/4/25 Sourdough FAIL
4/4/25 Sourdough fail! I knew from the dough that something was wrong. The dough was very sticky and not as firm as normal. More than likely, I over proofed my dough🤦🏼‍♀️ Because of this, the bread didn’t rise and became dense and gummy. Hopefully tomorrow I have better luck.
KB

KB

0 likes

Sourdough Fail
I was teaching my fiancé how to perform coil folds when the dough ripped. We are using this dough to make bagels, so I don’t think it will affect the final product much, thankfully. This is your reminder to be gentle with your dough and to pay attention to the amount of tension you’re building.
Kel💗✨

Kel💗✨

34 likes

He killed my sourdough starter😭
Morgan Maldonado

Morgan Maldonado

1 like

Sourdough inclusion fails…
Clearly not the breadwinner here
Lemon8er

Lemon8er

0 likes

A hand holds a round, scored sourdough loaf with an uneven rise, set against a kitchen background. The text overlay asks, "WHAT WENT WRONG With My Sourdough," reflecting the article's theme of baking mistakes.
Everything I Did Wrong Making Sourdough 🍞
I have been making sourdough for about 4 months now and my bread has always turned out pretty good. I’d have to say this is probably my worst loaf yet (or I’m starting to become more critical of my loafs) due to some silky mistakes. At the end of the day the loaf was still delicious! and was great
Gillian Spors

Gillian Spors

2 likes

Sourdough Starter Fail?
Is this a fail? Can my sourdough friends let me know? What did I do wrong? #sourdoughfail #sourdoughbeginner #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughjourney #breadmaker
✨Cheyenne Dez✨

✨Cheyenne Dez✨

0 likes

Sourdough starter fail
always keep some discard on backup in case you mess up your starter 😅 #sourdough starter
Patricia's homestead journey

Patricia's homestead journey

2 likes

Sourdough Fail
Toddler put me to sleep last night before shaping. OVERPROOFED Sourdough isn’t the worst thing ever. Focaccia Time!
Caitlin➖Homestead in the City

Caitlin➖Homestead in the City

0 likes

How to Tell if Sourdough is Overproofed
Wondering if your bulk fermentation has left you with overproofed sourdough? Bulk fermentation occurs from the moment you add the starter to your dough until the time when you pre-shape it. Shoot for a 78º F dough temperature on bulk fermentation (The biggest influence on dough temperature is th
Nancy | Sourdough Living

Nancy | Sourdough Living

7 likes

A close-up of a bubbly, light-colored liquid in a clear glass container, likely a sourdough starter, with the text "how we started" overlaid.
A ball of raw dough resting in a clear glass bowl, surrounded by white flour, with the text "first loaf!" overlaid.
A close-up of a round, raw dough ball in a clear glass bowl, with remnants of flour on the sides of the bowl.
when you get 2 inspired by tiktok & ur bread flops
LMAOOOO oops better luck next time huh #breadtok #regular bread in dutch oven #bakingfail #letschat #sourdoughfail
ari🦋

ari🦋

2 likes

sourdough dehydration journey
The sourdough dehydration journey is officially a SUCCESS! 🌾✨ I’ve been waiting for this moment, and seeing it all come together in these jars is pure gold. Plus, we’ve got the bags packed and ready because around here, the bake never stops. My husband is getting his high-protein breakfast, I’m get
Between_Certainty

Between_Certainty

1 like

sourdough fail
i think i over proofed but that’s okay 🤎 . . . #homesteader #homemaker #homeschooler #sourdoughjourney #sourdough
jade

jade

10 likes

signs your sourdough starter is ready!
it probably won’t look THIS crazy, but there will be signs! - - - - - #sourdough #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughstarter #sourdoughstartertips #breadforbeginners
Crust n’ Cozy

Crust n’ Cozy

678 likes

Sourdough Frustration is Real
It’s your starters world & your just living in it. #sourdoughfail #sourdoughbeginner #sourdoughlife #sourdoughjourney
MamaBriBriOfficial

MamaBriBriOfficial

13 likes

Sourdough fail, or victory?
This feels like a bit of a PSA for type-A perfectionist home bakers that consider no ears a fail. Like me! I knew during initial stengthening (when I combined my autolyse and levain) that I added a smidge too much water and my rise would be a little off. What I’ve learned, a year into sourdough bak
Tara

Tara

1 like

Sourdough baking isn’t for the weak or impatient 😂🫶
#sourdoughfail #cookingcomedy #bakingfails #bakingyourlifesweeter🍪
Sami j

Sami j

1 like

Sourdough “Rules” I Don’t Follow
#sourdough #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughideas #sourdoughtips #sourdoughbeginner
hannah🌻

hannah🌻

409 likes

@Tostitos send help 😂😂
Erica Renee

Erica Renee

14 likes

How to fix a sluggish sourdough starter🍞
One of the most common questions I get asked-so here are my tips for fixing a sluggish starter, one who is rising slowly, or having trouble giving you the bread that you want. Link is in our bio if you’d like to bake with our sourdough starter! She comes live, ready to be fed and baked with! Happy
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

32 likes

A golden-brown, round sourdough loaf with a score mark and flour dusting rests on a dark, perforated baking pan. The text "first sourdough loaf" is overlaid, indicating a baking attempt.
I know what I did wrong
Currently strengthening my starter and going to let it bulk ferment longer next time but it could’ve been worse!!
TikTokTas

TikTokTas

0 likes

Sourdough fail.
Attempt #1 ,000,006 at sourdough: nailed the ‘rustic vibe,’ missed the ‘edible bread’ part. Apparently, I’m raising a starter to betray me every single time. 🥖💔 On the bright side, my family now has a lifetime supply of doorstops. (This one was like a friggin cinderblock.) Maybe bread just isn
Jovie Saint

Jovie Saint

1 like

First sourdough fail
Jamieandher4saints

Jamieandher4saints

1 like

See more