What I did differently: first loaf vs. second loaf

🌾 First loaf: no hydration research, rushed the process, counter proofed 4 hours, baked too hot → burned top and bottom.

🌾 Second loaf: researched hydration, cold proofed overnight, baked low and slow with parchment → huge improvement.

#fyp #sourdoughbaker #sourdoughstarter #sourdoughbread #baking #embracevulnerability

5/4 Edited to

... Read moreBaking sourdough bread can often feel like a balancing act between science and art. From my journey, one of the most critical factors was understanding hydration. The first loaf suffered from rushed attempts without proper hydration research, leading to dense crumb and overbaked crust. Adjusting the hydration ratio after researching similar baking guides made a noticeable difference in dough texture and rise. Cold proofing overnight is another game changer. This slower fermentation allows yeast and bacteria to develop flavor and structure naturally, which cannot be rushed. I noticed that after cold proofing, the dough became easier to handle and had a more open crumb after baking. The baking method itself also impacted the final loaf quality. Initially, baking at a high temperature caused the top and bottom of the bread to burn, while the inside was undercooked. Switching to a low and slow baking technique with parchment paper helped distribute heat more evenly and prevented scorching. Parchment also made it simpler to transfer the dough onto the baking surface, preventing damage. Combining these adjustments transformed my sourdough attempts from disappointing to satisfying. For novice bakers, focusing on hydration, proofing times, and baking temperature can significantly elevate the quality of homemade sourdough bread. In addition, engaging with sourdough communities online, such as those tagging #sourdoughbaker and #sourdoughstarter, provides valuable insights and support, making the learning curve more manageable. Embracing patience and being open to learning from each loaf, including failures, is essential for progress in sourdough baking.

Related posts

First vs Latest 🥖
#sourdough #sourdoughbread #sourdoughlife #homemade sourdough bread 🍞
Faith

Faith

7 likes

first semi-successful loaf🫶
best loaf i have made so far.. little underproofed, any suggestions?? #sourdough #lemon8challenge
Becca

Becca

3 likes

My 1st & Second Sourdough Loaves
I started my #sourdough journey a few weeks ago. And it’s def a learning curve. The first thing I learned is that my house is cold lol. It didn’t activate my starter properly enough. And so my very first load was flat and dense, like a cake. So I googled everything and landed on the fact that
💕 Andrea 💕

💕 Andrea 💕

18 likes

Part 1. Ellie’s First Loaf
Make Ellie's first sourdough loaf with me. 350 grams filtered water 100 grams starter 500 grams bread flour 10 grams salt #sourdough #sourdoughtok #homebaking #bakingtherapy #sourdoughbread
Ellie

Ellie

11 likes

A rustic, round loaf of homemade bread with a golden-brown crust, sitting in a clear glass baking dish. Text overlay reads: "FIRST EVER LOAF AND WHAT I'VE MADE SINCE."
A hand holds a slice of the round, light-colored homemade bread, revealing its soft, airy interior. The rest of the loaf, partially sliced, rests on a metal cooling rack.
A light-colored, oblong loaf of bread, sliced horizontally to show its airy, porous interior, resting on parchment paper. A serrated knife is visible nearby.
First ever loaf and what I’ve made since
#baking #bread #homemade #homemade #yummy
Trauma queen

Trauma queen

1 like

my second sourdough loaf ever!!
i tried making my first one in january and it came out a flat disc, then i made a second one and it came out ok, edible, but this one came out so much better!!! #sourdoughlife #letschat #CommentChallenge #sourdough bread #homemade sourdough bread 🍞
ari🦋

ari🦋

9 likes

🍞 The Great Bread Showdown: Which Loaf Actually Wins?
Not all bread is created equal! I put 6 popular loaves to the test, and the difference was pretty surprising. 🏆 Dave’s Killer Bread Organic Whole Wheat with Seeds — 75/100 The clear winner! Whole wheat, seeds, organic ingredients, and a solid protein boost. The others? 👀 Most scored much lo
Rooted+Real

Rooted+Real

0 likes

The biggest loaf I’ve ever baked
INGREDIENTS 1000 grams Bread flour 650 grams Filtered water 200 grams Active (leavened) sourdough starter 20 grams salt INSTRUCTIONS Autolyse: In a large bowl weigh out 1,000 grams of flour, 200 grams of active sourdough starter, 650 grams of warm filtered water, and 20 grams of salt.
Liza Zykin

Liza Zykin

577 likes

1st and 2nd loafs I’ve made!
I’ve been learning how to make sourdough bread! And this is the product of my hard work 😚 it’s not much and I definitely have more to learn but it was so fun to do!! 🥰 #homemade sourdough bread 🍞
Jellybean19

Jellybean19

0 likes

Very first sourdough loaf
I am very impressed with my first three ever sourdough loaves!!! I didn’t set high hopes knowing that there are always fails on the first few. But I nailed it. #sourdough #firsttimer
B3@utifulM0mm@

B3@utifulM0mm@

11 likes

regular loaf
my recipe for sourdough part 1 #sourdough #recipe #bread #food #baking
beccasbakerysourdough

beccasbakerysourdough

35 likes

A hand holds a freshly baked, scored sourdough loaf with a golden crust. The background features a brick wall and a framed painting. Overlay text reads: "Stupid Sourdough Mistakes I've made so you don't have to!"
A light-colored proofing basket (banneton) contains a linen liner and a red spatula. Overlay text advises new sourdough bakers to get a dehydrated starter or one from a friend for a strong start.
A baked sourdough loaf rests on parchment paper in a kitchen setting. Overlay text describes a mistake: washing hands with strong-scented soap, which made the bread taste like a candle.
Stupid Sourdough Mistakes I’ve Made
If you've made a dumb sourdough mistake, odds are l've probably made it too! Sourdough really is a journey. #sourdough #breadtok #sourdoughforbeginners 💡Tips for beginners: get an established starter 📝 Reflect on mistakes: don't use strong scented soap when handling dough
Free State Flourworks 🌾

Free State Flourworks 🌾

59 likes

My fist loaf
I did it, I was so excited it worked this time. #sourdoughlife #sourdoughbeginner #sourdough #bread #freshbread
Frances

Frances

2 likes

The score vs The loaf!
there’s so many ways to score sourdough, this is one of my favorite methods! - - - - - #sourdough #sourdoughtok #baking #artisanbread #BreadTok
Crust n’ Cozy

Crust n’ Cozy

9 likes

My very first Sourdough Loaf
She needs a little work but I couldn’t be happier with how she turned out! #sourdough #firstloaf #bread #fyp
Emili

Emili

0 likes

My first loaf to my most recent
#sourdough #loaf #sourdoughbaker
Manda

Manda

5 likes

My first sourdough loaf of 2024 vs..
Truth is I started baking after my miscarriage at the beginning of 2024. It was an outlet for me that I’ve grown to love and saved me in a way. I had my rainbow baby at the end of 2024 and plan to continue baking ❤️🥰 #athomebaker #sourdoughbaker #sourdoughjourney #embracevulnerability #rai
Emily | your SAHM bestie💗

Emily | your SAHM bestie💗

27 likes

First Loaf Attempt from C. Sourdoughthian!
Thought I’d do a break from the autoimmune disease parts with me attempting my first loaf from her! It is a start, many mistakes were made but I am getting there!! 🤍 . . . #sourdough #homesteading #homemade #fyp
Ravyn | Homestead & Creations

Ravyn | Homestead & Creations

1 like

QUICK & EASY ARTISAN LOAF 🍞
I love sourdough but boy it takes a lot of time and effort. This is the closest recipe I have found that mimics the texture and feel of sourdough. It takes only a couple hours from mix to table! #bread #baking #breadrecipe #cooking
Alexandra Balut

Alexandra Balut

41 likes

I made my first loaf
#sourdoughbaking
Lmeg

Lmeg

5 likes

An orange tabby cat sits in a classic loaf position on a brown carpet, with its eyes slightly closed. The image includes a text overlay asking to 'RATE MY LOAF 1-10'.
An orange tabby cat lies on a brown carpet in a relaxed half-loaf position, looking to the right. Its front paws are tucked under its body.
A fluffy orange tabby cat is seen from behind in a loaf position on a brown carpet, with its head slightly turned to the right.
Rate my loaf 1-10
Day 25: my mom is OBSESSED when I loaf. I just started loafing everywhere. Comment your score and a pic of your loaf 143 #halfloaf #loaf #catloaf #lazypigs #miniloaf
_H_D_4_

_H_D_4_

17 likes

ELOISE SOURDOUGH ASMR… i cannot believe this happened ☠️💀 recipe below on how to make 2 sourdough loafs: 725g warm filtered water 250g active sourdough starter (eloise) 30g salt 1000g bread flour - mix ingredients together - let sit for one hour - perform 4 sets of stretch and
gigi

gigi

10.6K likes

Part 2. Ellie’s First Loaf
Shape my first sourdough loaf with me! #sourdough #sourdoughtok #homebaking #bakingtherapy #sourdoughbread
Ellie

Ellie

9 likes

Second loaf 🥰
Richard walked in and said oooo smells good in here!! And I agree, man i missed the smell of bread in the house 😍 its been a while The second loaf is baking!! We will see how it is, I didn’t add anymore flour to it and it was pretty sticky. And only let it rise for a little less than two hours.
Itsjustme

Itsjustme

3 likes

Second Loaf!!!
#lemon8diarychallenge #sourdough #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughbread
Katy Kat

Katy Kat

2 likes

Two freshly baked, round loaves of bread with golden-brown crusts and white flour dusting are cooling on a metal rack, showcasing a successful 'double loaf day'.
Double loaf day!
Alliey | SAHM 💗

Alliey | SAHM 💗

1 like

FIRST LOAF!!
i went a little MIA for a while life got very busy but a HUGE update, Juno made 2 BEAUTIFUL breads today! a stunning sourdough loaf and an incredible garlic herb and cheese focaccia! i’m over the moon 🫶🏼 #sourdoughloaf #sourdough bread #sourdoughmom #sourdoughjourney #homemade sourdough
faithy💐

faithy💐

5 likes

Major improvement from my first loaf 🥰
#growth #growthmindset #patience #sourdough #loaf
Andrea

Andrea

2 likes

Apple Fritter Loaf 🍎
* 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened * 3/4 cup white granulated sugar * 2 large eggs, room temperature * 1/2 cup milk, room temperature * 2 tsp vanilla extract * 1 1/2 cup all purpose flour * 2 tsp baking powder * 1/4 tsp salt * 1/2 tsp cinnamon * 2 large honeycrisp apples + 2 tbsp white su
Zeetheintrovert

Zeetheintrovert

2817 likes

A rectangular sourdough loaf with a golden-brown crust and flour dusting, resting on a white checkered cloth. The image has a text overlay that reads "Sourdough Loaves My 2nd & 3rd".
A top-down view of a rectangular sourdough loaf with a golden-brown crust and flour dusting, resting on a white checkered cloth, illuminated by sunlight.
A rectangular sourdough loaf with a golden-brown crust and decorative leaf-like scoring on its flour-dusted side, resting on a white checkered cloth.
My second and third sourdough loaves!!!
My first one was a complete flop, but these were sooo much better!! Crazy how changing one little thing can make such a big difference! If you want my “Sourdough Know All” digital file let me know in the comments and I’ll send you the link!🫶🏻 ✨Happy baking✨ #sourdoughlife #sourdoughbre
Kc Stefanski

Kc Stefanski

3 likes

Second loaf. Delicious.
Kellijo1990

Kellijo1990

0 likes

The first three loaves
The first three loaves out of fifty! This week we made a classic loaf, jalapeño and cheddar loaf, and an olive and herb loaf! Each one was delicious! I can’t wait to share more loaf recipes with you all as we go through the next forty-seven loaves! #loaf #sourdoughloaf #sourdoughstarter
Emilee Merino

Emilee Merino

8 likes

A freshly baked, round sourdough loaf with a scored top, dusted with flour, resting in a white Dutch oven lined with parchment paper.
A close-up of the baked sourdough loaf on a red cutting board, highlighting a raised crust section referred to as "the little ear."
A sourdough loaf cut in half, showing its internal crumb structure, which is described as still gummy and dense but improved from a previous attempt.
My 2nd sourdough loaf!
This one was MUCH better, but still not perfect. I ate half the loaf in one sitting 😅 sourdough is DELICIOUS. I’m going to keep trying! #sourdough #bread #baking #sahm #Lemon8Diary #food #healthylifestyle2024 #groceryessentials
Brandi🍒

Brandi🍒

3 likes

My first loaf 🙌🏼
#gettoknowme #breadforbeginners
Rosa C. French

Rosa C. French

2 likes

A sourdough loaf cut in half, revealing a distinct swirled pattern within its crumb. The interior shows a mix of air pockets and denser areas, held by a hand.
A baked sourdough loaf with decorative scoring on its golden-brown crust, lightly dusted with flour, resting on a metal cooling rack.
A sourdough loaf sliced in half, displaying an open and irregular crumb structure with varying sizes of air pockets. The interior is light brown.
First Loafs
Well… they are definitely either under proofed or over proofed, not sure which one. So I need to work on my bulk fermentation next loaf I try. But this was my first attempts so now I know what I need to practice and focus more on for next time 😜 #sourdough #starter #sourdoughstarter #cel
JustTayBeing_Tayy

JustTayBeing_Tayy

1 like

The Score vs The Loaf
quick sourdough loaf for the next few days! I went with a quick classic score B)
Crust n’ Cozy

Crust n’ Cozy

10 likes

Part 3. Ellie’s First Loaf
Score and bake Ellie with me! #sourdoughbaker #breadmaking #sourdough #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughbread
Ellie

Ellie

21 likes

First loaf of the year 🎉
#sourdough #doughmama
Alliey | SAHM 💗

Alliey | SAHM 💗

3 likes

My first loaf
I made my first sourdough loaf last night and it turned out so good. I’m pretty proud of myself. #sourdoughloaf #sourdoughlife #sourdoughjourney
Veronica

Veronica

0 likes

✨Easy loaf shaping 101✨
Watch me shape this dough using the loaf pan bake method! 🍞 It’s super simple—no fancy techniques needed. All you have to do is build a little tension in the dough so it holds its shape and bakes up beautifully. #breadbaking #homemadebread #loafpanlove
mrsgrandin

mrsgrandin

9 likes

My First Cinnamon Sugar Sourdough Loaf… Flop?
I made my first cinnamon sugar sourdough loaf back in February and as soon as I started shaping the dough, the cinnamon sugar started leaking everywhere! The top was covered in liquid cinnamon sugar after the cold proof in the fridge. I baked it anyway because, why not, and the inside was still del
Magen Wolmart

Magen Wolmart

12 likes

My second sourdough loaf
T’s Tasty Pucks+

T’s Tasty Pucks+

2 likes

Made my first loaf of bread 🥰
⭐️Overall rating: /10:10 Tried my first batch of bread and it came out soo cute! Very satisfying. #breadmaking
Shay 💗

Shay 💗

3 likes

A heart-shaped sourdough loaf, rated 3/10, is shown on a white paper towel. The crust appears lumpy and not smooth, with a golden-brown color. Text indicates it's gummy.
A heart-shaped sourdough loaf, rated 4.5/10, rests in a baking dish lined with parchment paper. The crust is smoother than the first loaf, but scoring marks are barely visible, and it's still described as gummy.
A close-up of a sourdough loaf, rated 7/10, in a baking dish. It features prominent scoring patterns dusted with flour, indicating improved technique. The loaf is golden-brown, described as slightly gummy and oversalted.
Rating my sourdough loafs 🍞
Sourdough has been...an adventure. I wanted to show you guys what I've been working on lately! The loafs definitely get better looking with time 😅 What are some sourdough tips? Im gonna need all the help i can get! 🩷 #sourdoughbread #lemon8challenge #nobuy2025 #sourdoughjourne
Ren ;)

Ren ;)

14 likes

My First loaf of
Made my first loaf of sourdough bread this morning!😍 crispy crust, soft inside, the smell is 🤌🏼. #sourdoughlife #sourdoughjourney #sourdoughloaf #sourdoughcreations
Abby Foster

Abby Foster

3 likes

An unbaked Jewish Rye Bread loaf on parchment paper inside an oven, with text indicating it's the first homemade attempt and a new era of bread making.
A light-colored, unbaked Jewish Rye Bread loaf with a scored top, resting on parchment paper inside an oven, ready for baking.
A freshly baked, golden-brown Jewish Rye Bread loaf cooling on a wire rack on a granite countertop, with text stating it came out perfect.
My first Homemade Jewish Rye Bread loaf
After it cooled, made several Grilled cheese sandwiches - everyone loved them. I need to get some dark rye flour for my next loaf, but will use same recipe again for sure. #homemade bread #RyeBread #BetterForYouBread #HomemadeIsBest
LeAnn Wheeler

LeAnn Wheeler

6 likes

I made my first loaf of bread!
#momlife #sahm #homemaker #traditional
Lis Daily | UGC

Lis Daily | UGC

1899 likes

My first Loaf
#Lemon8Scrapbook
HImynameIS

HImynameIS

1 like

POV: You thought it was a normal loaf… then you saw the inside. 🤯
Chicken. Waffles. Sourdough. I regret nothing. 🤌🍞 #sourdoughloaf #loaf #sourdough #emergingcreator #chickenandwaffles @Captain Lemon8
Sourdough Savage

Sourdough Savage

31 likes

Overproofed Sourdough loaf or Perfection?
Everyone has their own goal when baking sourdough bread. Some like their crumb to be very hole-y and open, others prefer a slightly denser loaf, but I find that more and more people like a fluffy, closed crumb. One where the butter and jam won’t seep through the holes yet it’s very soft and fluffy.
The Sourdough Lady

The Sourdough Lady

33 likes

Sourdough starter ratios for beginners
Save and share this video for reference! #sourdoughbeginner #sourdoughforbeginners #sourdoughstarter #sourdoughdiscard #sourdoughideas
Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

Little Ranch Family🏠🪴🍞

2039 likes

From Starter to loaf
I just started my sourdough journey last month and it has truly been a life change for me. I am less stressed and able to provide bread for my family and friends that is not full of preservatives and junk. Next stop opening my micro bakery. #sourdoughjourney #sourdoughrevolution #sourdoughcommu
Whittley Havis

Whittley Havis

3 likes

First loaf is a success 👏🏼
She isn’t perfect but she was a labor of love and I am soo proud! #sourdoughbread #sourdough #baking #bread #cooking Delaware
Hillary🖤

Hillary🖤

5 likes

Which Loaf Are You? 🥰
Respectfully… some of you are blueberry lemon cream cheese and don’t even know it 🫐🥖 Drop your loaf and let’s talk about it.
Crust & Crumb | Sourdough

Crust & Crumb | Sourdough

0 likes

I love a good loaf either way.
#catloaf #fluffygalgang #cats #trend #fyp
Heathfromthewayback2

Heathfromthewayback2

6 likes

First successful loaf 🥲
lil burnt but that’s okay #sourdough #loaf
jen b 🤎

jen b 🤎

0 likes

Behind every loaf… 🍞
Meet Bready White 🫧—my 3-year-old sourdough starter and the heart of Bubbly Co. Every loaf starts with a little wild yeast, patience, and love. Want to start your own? I’ll share tips soon! Already have a starter? SHARE THE NAME! 👇 #sourdoughdesign #feed sourdough starter #sourdoughstarter
Bubbly Co. Sourdough

Bubbly Co. Sourdough

46 likes

See more