Peanut butter cup blizzard ✨40 grams of protein ✨

One recipe makes FOUR creami containers:

✨4 fairlife chocolate milks (the ones with 30g protein)

✨1 container (48g) @simplydessertsnatural pudding mixes (vanilla or chocolate)

✨1 cup (220g) 2% cottage cheese (I like @good_culture)

Optional: a squirt of stevia for extra sweetness if you like (the cottage cheese adds a little salty punch so it’s a great compliment to that)

Toppings (included in nutrition)

✨1 tbsp (8 grams) peanut butter powder

✨1 @skinnydipped dark chocolate peanut butter cup

Either combine everything in a high-speed blender or if you have a smaller ninja bullet like I do, you’ll have to do half the recipe at a time. If you do this it is 24 grams of pudding powder and 110 g (half cup) cottage cheese.

One blended, split evenly into four different containers and freeze overnight or for about 12 hours.

A crucial part of the next-day mixing process is making sure I allow the frozen-solid container to sit out for at least 30 minutes. If I’m in a hurry, I will stick it in hot water for 10 to 15 before I begin blending in the @ninjakitchen Creami blender.

I like to add the pb powder for the final cycle blend, then the chopped up pb cups on top.

In no world should something packed with this much nutrition taste so great…but it does so I had to share. I hope you try it and love it too!! Let me know!

#peanutbutterlover #peanutbutterchocolate #pbcups #ninjacreami #highprotein

2025/9/14 Edited to

... Read moreThis peanut butter cup blizzard is a fantastic way to satisfy your sweet tooth while maintaining a high-protein diet. Using Fairlife chocolate milk, which contains 30 grams of protein per bottle, together with cottage cheese and protein-rich pudding powder, ensures you get the muscle-building benefits without sacrificing flavor. The addition of peanut butter powder and skinny dipped dark chocolate peanut butter cups enhances the taste while adding fiber and healthy fats. Freezing the mixture overnight helps create a creamy texture similar to traditional ice cream, but with the added bonus of being low in sugar and high in protein. When preparing this recipe, blending half the ingredients at a time in a smaller bullet blender ensures a smooth consistency. Allowing the frozen containers to thaw slightly before blending with the Ninja Creami blender guarantees the perfect creamy result. Adding peanut butter powder in the final blend cycle intensifies the peanut flavor. This recipe is ideal for meal prep, as it makes four servings that can be stored in containers and enjoyed as a convenient post-workout snack or a guilt-free dessert. Optional stevia can be added to adjust sweetness without increasing calories. Using ingredients like Good Culture cottage cheese and Simply Desserts Natural pudding mixes helps keep the recipe clean and junk-free. The combination provides a balanced profile of protein, fiber, and healthy fats, making it suitable for those looking to build lean muscle, support recovery, or simply enjoy a nutritious frozen treat. Overall, this peanut butter cup blizzard perfectly balances indulgence and nutrition, showing that a high-protein dessert can be delicious and easy to make at home.

Related posts

Do you have 3 ingredients & five minutes?
Packed with 40 G’s of protein and 240 Calories try this personal peanut butter cup as a snack or dessert to meet your protein goal 💪. Melt some chocolate for the top layer put it in the freezer. Once the chocolate topping is hardened you can store it in the refrigerator. Crack into the top chocola
Allie Carlini

Allie Carlini

545 likes

A person's hand holds a clear glass bowl filled with a creamy, light brown high-protein peanut butter cup blizzard. The dessert contains dark specks and two round chocolate pieces, with a golden spoon visible. Text overlay identifies the dish as 'CREAMY HIGH PROTEIN PEANUT BUTTER CUP BLIZZARD'.
Creamy high protein peanut butter cup blizzard
YOU GUYS just came up with this idea and it is AMAZING! With about 25g of protein 😊🤪 #blizzard #highproteinsweets #protein #proteinicecream #foryoupage
Calorie Deficit Chef 👩🏼‍🍳💋

Calorie Deficit Chef 👩🏼‍🍳💋

130 likes

Peanut butter & Oreo Protein blizzard 🤤
Try this as your next post workout treat or an additional way to get more protein in!! #proteinicecream #proteinblizzard #highproteinrecipe #highproteinsnack #recipevideos #recipeidea #eatyourprotein #foodisfuel
bianca_villers

bianca_villers

19 likes

3 Ingredient Protein Peanut Butter Cups
# #healthyhighproteinsnack #chocolate peanut butter #peanutbutter #protein powder #peanutbuttercup
Allie Carlini

Allie Carlini

937 likes

Chocolate peanut butter cup protein ice cream!
Incredibly smooth and creamy chocolate protein ice cream, with homemade dark chocolate peanut butter cups throughout! Gluten free, refined sugar free, and dairy free / vegan, too!! #ninjacreami #peanutbuttercup #homemadeicecream #healthydessert #proteindessertrecipe
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

1669 likes

Easy 40g Protein Shake
This is my go to shake to get in that extra protein every day. It’s so yummy and always gone within 5 minutes of me making it 🤣😋 💵 Where to purchase: 💵 •Milk and bananas at any store lol • PB fit powder I got at Walmart, but I’m sure they sell at any other big stores like Target too #highp
c🫶🏼

c🫶🏼

49 likes

Protein Resee’s peanut butter cup
(Sorry for the typo 🥲) 1/3 cup Greek yogurt 1/4 cup PB fit powder melted dark chocolate chips on top Flaky salt on top (optional) Put in the fridge or freezer for about 20 minutes and serve Absolutely delicious and only about 250 calories and 24 grams of protein. #proteindessert #pr
Savannah

Savannah

100 likes

Protein packed peanut cutter cups 🍫😘
MY FAVORITE protein treat by FAR 🤭🍫 Chocolate: 10 oz semi sweet chocolate chips 2 tablespoons coconut oil *heat up the mix and pour 1/4 into each muffin liner * refrigerate for 15 minutes in the muffin tins Peanut butter mix: 1 scoop of @ghostlifestyle whey peanut butter cereal milk pr
Savannah Wright

Savannah Wright

1134 likes

A hand with pink nail polish holds a clear container of chocolate protein ice cream, topped with chopped Reese's peanut butter cups. Text overlays indicate "42g of protein" and "protein reeses ice cream w/ the ninja creami".
PROTEIN REESE’S ICE CREAM 🍫🍦
chocolate reese’s pb cup ice cream is hands down my favorite and always my go to flavor!! decided I should make a protein version at home and I’m obsessed it’s AMAZING!!!! ingredients: 🍫fairlife core power elite chocolate protein shake (42g of protein) 🍫1 tbsp cream cheese melted 🍫1 tbsp organ
ganna sumar

ganna sumar

316 likes

Healthy Reese’s PB Cup Protein Ice Cream
-3/4 bottle chocolate or vanilla protein drink -2-3 pumps peanut butter cup SF syrup (If you have a chocolate PB premier protein shake you can use that as well) -mix and place in freezer for at least 12 hours -place in ninja creamy and blend on light ice cream mode -add in the rest of the 1/4
Jami

Jami

4 likes

High protein peanut butter cup dessert dip!
This velevty smooth peanut butter cup dip is high protein, low sugar, gluten free, and irresistibly delicious! It's made in just minutes, topped with homemade 4 ingredient peanut butter cups, and tastes great dipped with graham crackers, or even just by the spoonful! 🥄 #peanutbuttercups
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

382 likes

40g of protein never looked this good
If you’re trying to hit your protein goals without feeling like you’re eating “protein food,” this chocolate peanut butter ice cream is the move. Thick, creamy, sweet, and secretly packed with protein thanks to cottage cheese. Dessert girl era, but make it nourishing. Ingredients: 1 cup cotta
Sienna Paige

Sienna Paige

64 likes

Protein Peanut Butter Cup! 🥜
Mix all ingredients (besides choc chips) Melt choc chips and spread on top Freeze for 20 min to harden chocolate ***pro tips: -splash some milk or cream in with choc chips to melt easier -if prepping for next day, keep in fridge until 20 min prior & freeze then
kb

kb

89 likes

High Protein Peanut Butter Desert Cups🥜🍫56g p 300c
High Protein Peanut Butter Desert Cups made from collagen peptides, dried peanut butter and water #recipe #protein #health #lowcalorie #snack #desert #fyp #foryou #foryoupage #viral #fitness #looseweight #collagen #chocolate #peanutbutter #peanutbuttercups #reeces #food
Viggo Maximilian

Viggo Maximilian

907 likes

Healthy Peanut Butter Cup Dessert
I like this fit dessert or breakfast! It’s high protein and delicious! #healthydessertideas #highproteindessert #healthydessert #healthyrecipes
Arlyn

Arlyn

109 likes

CHOCOLATE PB NINJA CREAMI PROTEIN ICE CREAM ✨✨
260 calories & 30g protein for the chocolate pb ninja creami base!! ✨✨ #proteinicecream #ninjacreamirecipe #ninjacreamiproteinicecream #ninjacreamiproteinrecipe #ninjacreamiicecream
Kayla Berman

Kayla Berman

77 likes

40g of protein
#gettoknowme #fitnessjourneymotivation #fit #inspo #influencer Oklahoma City
Kim Taylor| Oklahoma

Kim Taylor| Oklahoma

6 likes

Healthier Homemade Peanut Butter Cups
These Healthy Peanut Butter Cups are an easy snack or dessert. By being made with peanut butter and/or peanut butter powder, they are high in protein and lower in calorie than the store-bought version. The extra protein will keep you full while also satisfying your sweet tooth. INGREDIENTS
Jes

Jes

188 likes

CHOCOLATE PROTEIN FROSTY 🍦
On repeat in my kitchen 🔁🍫 What you need: • frozen bananas 🍌 • peanut butter • almond milk • chocolate protein & blend it up thick 🍫🍌🍦 #proteinsmoothie #healthyrecipes #beautyfinds #lemon8review #dessertrecipe #fitnessmotivation #fitnessinspo #foodoflemon8 #lemon
ATX DIETITIAN

ATX DIETITIAN

24 likes

Ingredients for healthy frozen peanut butter cups: peanut butter, bananas, chocolate syrup, chocolate chips, cupcake liners in muffin tins, and a knife on a counter.
Sliced bananas on a cutting board, alongside a jar of peanut butter, chocolate syrup, chocolate chips, and cupcake liners in muffin tins.
Cupcake liners in a muffin tin filled with peanut butter, banana slices, and chocolate drizzle, with a jar of peanut butter and chocolate syrup nearby.
healthy frozen peanut butter cups 😋🤫
🍌🥜🍫 ingredients ⬇️⬇️ peanut butter sliced banana drizzle chocolate melted chocolate freeze for a few hours enjoy 🙂 #peanut butter #bananas #caramel #chocolate #peanutbuttercups
Najia_07_06

Najia_07_06

8 likes

Reese cup blizzard (in the ninja creami)
So dang good! #ninjacreami #ninjacreamirecipes #Recipe #icecream #reeses
Jenny Rae

Jenny Rae

122 likes

_Coffey_Break_98_

_Coffey_Break_98_

16 likes

A chocolate-colored protein blizzard in a clear cup, topped with whipped cream and crushed dark cookie pieces. The image features text overlay "3 INGREDIENT PROTEIN BLIZZARD" on a kitchen counter.
A hand holds a bottle of chocolate-flavored protein drink, with text overlay "Protein of choice". A bottle of chocolate syrup is blurred in the background.
A hand holds a bottle of zero sugar chocolate-flavored syrup, with text overlay "THIS IS A MUST". A can of whipped topping is blurred in the background.
3 ingredient protein blizzard
Recipe: 🔆fairlife chocolate milk, 🔆chocolate fudge pudding (extra chocolate flavor) 🔆Hershey sugar free sauce 🔆Crushed up mini Oreos to mix in I have no idea on macros sorry I’m advance! #lemon8diary #dayinmylife #hellolemon8 #springaesthetic #fashionfinds #healthylifestyle20
Bailee | FTM ✨

Bailee | FTM ✨

280 likes

protein brownie batter blizzard
🍫Protein brownie batter blizzard🍫 i use whey chocolate protein powder and i use peanut butter powder* * any greek yogurt you can use* * chop up built chocolate protein bar and put in bowl* * dark chocolate chips* * and bananas !! #chocolate protein powder #gymsnacks #gymgirl #protein #
-Alexandria

-Alexandria

3 likes

18g Protein Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups
Want a sweet treat but still hit your protein goals, try these high protein Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups!!! They have 18g of protein and taste amazing! ~ Recipe: • 1 cup of crushed granola • 2 1/2 tablespoons of peanut butter • Mix it together, then shape them however you’d like. • Freeze t
Rylee_M

Rylee_M

88 likes

Peanut butter cup
Creamy yogurt protein bowl packed with 25g of protein and just 6g of sugar—this peanut butter cup dream is both indulgent and balanced. I used sugar-free peanut butter, but you can lower calories even more with PBfit powder for an extra protein boost. Sweet cravings satisfied while staying full and
Kaiti S

Kaiti S

74 likes

Peanut butter and jelly fudge cups! 🥜🍇
These frozen peanut butter bites are incredibly satisfying for that pb&j fix! You've got the creamy, smooth peanut butter, the sweet raspberry filling, perfectly complimented with some flakey sea salt! You'll need 1 cup creamy organic peanut butter 2 tbsp melted coconut oil 2
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

1837 likes

Peanut Butter Protein Cup
1 cup of Greek yogurt 2-3 T of peanut butter Mix mix mix Top with melted chocolate chips, put in the fridge until it sets. Yum
Lemon868

Lemon868

1 like

A high protein Oreo blizzard in a clear cup, topped with crushed cookies, with a spoon holding a scoop. The image has text 'HIGH PROTIEN oreo blizzard SWIPE'.
A hand holds a black container of Oikos Pro vanilla yogurt, labeled with '20g Protein'. Text overlay says 'protein yogurt'.
A container of Dymatize Elite 100% Whey protein powder in Gourmet Vanilla flavor. Text overlay indicates '1/2 scoop of protein powder'.
High Protein Ninja Creami Oreo Blizzard
*approx 400 calories with 38 grams of protein for the entire pint* you can eat this WHOLE PINT guilt free and still reach your goals❤️ 🍦okios 20 grams protein yogurt 🍦1/2 scoop protein powder 🍦2 tbsp unsweetened almond milk 🍦mini oreos (i add them after blending my base) ENJOY ❤️
Makenna Gerres

Makenna Gerres

1111 likes

Protein Fluff Of The Day
Sweet, tangy, and oh-so fluffy! 🍋‍🟩 I told y’all I had more and OOOOOO if this one isn’t my favorite This Key Lime Pie Protein Fluff is the perfect light and creamy treat with a boost of protein! Recipe: 🤍 2 tbsp Cool Whip 🍋‍🟩 1 single-serve cup Key Lime Oikos Pro Yogurt 🧁 ~1 tbsp Sugar Free
With love, B. 💋

With love, B. 💋

1434 likes

Chocolate peanut butter protein shake
STOP drinking boring protein shakes! 🚨 This Reese’s-inspired protein shake is low in sugar, high in protein, and SO good! 💯 Here’s what you need: ⬇️ 🥤 1 Fairlife Chocolate Protein Shake 🥜 2-3 tbsp PB Fit Powder 🍫 Blend & enjoy! Would you try this? Comment 🥜 if YES! ⬇️ #Lemon8Food #L
Keep it simple with Fireball🔥

Keep it simple with Fireball🔥

43 likes

Several frozen Greek yogurt peanut butter bites, topped with chocolate chips, are arranged on parchment paper. The image also displays text indicating the recipe title and key ingredients like Greek yogurt, peanut butter, and honey/maple syrup.
A hand holds a chocolate-covered frozen Greek yogurt peanut butter bite, broken in half to reveal its creamy peanut butter interior. Other finished bites, sprinkled with sea salt, are visible on a white plate in the background.
A checklist of ingredients for frozen Greek yogurt peanut butter bites, including full-fat Greek yogurt, peanut butter powder, peanut butter, maple syrup, dark chocolate chips, coconut oil, and optional flaky sea salt.
Frozen yogurt peanut butter bites
Healthy snack/dessert option #healthydessertrecipes #peanutbutterballs #healthy snacks
okiemomofthree1990

okiemomofthree1990

686 likes

Peanut butter cup delight
Deshaye Andrea

Deshaye Andrea

7 likes

Healthier Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Bars
Think your favorite Klondike bar, but with a creamy peanut butter ice cream and chunks of homemade protein peanut butter cups! These ice cream bars are protein rich, gluten free, and have no refined sugar! #homemadeicecream #icecreambar #summerdessert #summerrecipes #healthydesserts
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

1011 likes

Peanut Butter Chocolate Protein Ice Cream👆
Peanut butter chocolate creami Ingredients: - [ ] 1.5c unsweetened almond milk - [ ] 1.5c non-fat fairlife milk - [ ] 2 tbsp PBfit - [ ] 1 tbsp cocoa powder - [ ] 1scp whey chocolate protein - [ ] 1 tbsp chocolate jello mix - [ ] Pinch salt - [ ] Pinch stevia Totals: - [ ] Calories: 38
OverallEats

OverallEats

37 likes

A close-up overhead view of chocolate protein ice cream with cookie pieces, served in a clear container with a pink spoon. Text overlays indicate it's a "CHOCOLATE NINJA CREAMi" with "35g protein."
A flat lay showing the ingredients for the protein ice cream: milk, protein powder, vanilla extract, and sugar-free chocolate pudding mix. Text overlays list the specific quantities for each ingredient.
A clear container holds a chocolate liquid mixture, ready for freezing. Text overlays provide step-by-step instructions for preparing the mixture, freezing it, and then processing it in an ice cream maker, including options for mix-ins.
High protein dessert
Almost 35g protein means having a pint of ice cream can be guilt free! I love having one of these after dinner as a sweet treat especially when tracking macros. It’s low fat, low calories & high protein plus it tastes almost identical to a frosty! It’s also very versatile meaning there are
Lyss

Lyss

445 likes

3 Ingredient Protein Frosty
Fairlife Chocolate Milk & Plain Milk Clean Simple Eats Brownie Batter Protein Powder #proteinicecream #ninja creami
bari.jess

bari.jess

235 likes

400 calorie protein ice cream👆
I make healthy easy to make recipes daily! A follow, like, and comment helps me so much! Enjoy some OverallEats:) Peanut butter Creami Ingredients - 1.5c Fat Free Fairlife milk - 0.5c egg whites - 1/2 banana - 3 tbsp PBFit - 1 tbsp cocoa powder - A bit of stevia and salt Topping/Mix in
OverallEats

OverallEats

112 likes

High Protein Giant Reese’s Cup
#highprotein #sweettreats #healthjourney #weightloss
Melissa

Melissa

2480 likes

Weight Watchers PeanutButter Cups
I absolutely love love love my Reese Peanut Cups🤤 But I’ve been pushing myself to stick to my Weight Watchers diet and they taste amazing ! PB2 🫶🏽- 3 Tablespoons Fat Free Cool Whip - Whole Container Sugar Free Chocolate Syrup 🍫- Drizzle on Top And stick in freezer for at least an hour 🤌🏼
Shelby Cormier

Shelby Cormier

139 likes

HIGH PROTEIN TREATS FOR GYM GAINS✨(quick and easy)
Some of the favorite protein sweet treats that i’ve been making on repeat🥰 When it comes to food, when i find my favorites i will eat them every single day until i can’t stand them anymore😂 The best part about it is, they’re just contributing more to the gym gains🤌🏼 #Lemon8partner #highprotei
Cassidy

Cassidy

168 likes

High Protein Ninja Creami Recipes 🍨🍦
Dessert every night? Why not! It’s so easy to get all my protein in with the ninja Creami! 25 to 40 G of protein and under 250 calories for a pint 😍. Have your dessert! @Lemon8 Food #lemon8food #highproteindessert #proteindessertrecipe #ninjacreami #easysnacks #easyrecipe #protei
Nydizzle🌷✨

Nydizzle🌷✨

829 likes

Healthy + High Protein Snickers Blizzard!
This delicious snickers blizzard is gluten free, dairy free, has no refined sugar, and it's SO satisfying! You'll need frozen banana Froze zucchini or cauliflower (both tasteless!! Or can use ice) medjool dates Chocolate protein powder Cacao / cocoa powder hemp hearts (or chia o
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

132 likes

High Protein Peanut Butter Cup Whip
Creamy. Sweet. Chocolate shell on top. No protein powder needed. Just real food blended smooth. What you need • 1 cup low fat cottage cheese • 1 tbsp peanut butter OR 2 tbsp PB2 powder • 1 to 2 tsp maple syrup or sweetener • Pinch salt • 1 tbsp melted dark chocolate How to make it
food4thoughtlog

food4thoughtlog

5 likes

Peanut butter cup protein bars!
Gluten free, low sugar, and high protein "Reese's" bars! With a peanut butter cookie dough like base, a dreamy chocolate ganache topping, and protein peanut butter cups! Just slice a PB protein bar up, and place in mini muffin liners with melted dark chocolate! #proteinbars
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

2029 likes

HEALTHY Dunkaroo dip 258 calories 40g of PROTEIN 😳
Definitely nostalgic to us 90s babies. When I tell yall this is sooooo good I mean it! Pair it with some fruit perfection for real 😋🤤 #proteindip #healthyrecipes #caloriedefict #transformation
Destiny

Destiny

2443 likes

easiest 8g of protein hidden in each bite 🤤
instructions: mix 1 cup Greek yogurt, 1 tbsp hot honey + 1 scoop peanut butter protein powder. optional: top with peanut butter and peanuts. freeze. 6 servings total.
Laila Ayubi

Laila Ayubi

36 likes

Easy protein bites~ chocolate peanut butter cup 🍫🥜
i can’t stop making these 😭 they really help me curve my ice cream addiction! i love eating them after the gym 💪🏼 tips: •make little divots in each piece once you’ve placed them on the baking sheet (as shown in pic) it just makes it easier to keep the toppings from rolling off (s/n: yes i
Jo~

Jo~

368 likes

Protein peanut butter cups
I have goals but could never say no to sweets so I’ll just make a better version to reach my goals with chocolate 😏 #chocolateproteinballs #highproteincookies #proteindesserts #recipes #summerbod
Missa.Issa

Missa.Issa

20 likes

Ingredients for a high-protein fruit dip, including vanilla yogurt and peanut butter powder, displayed alongside sliced red apples on a white plate. The image highlights an easy and healthy snack idea.
HIGH PROTEIN FRUIT DIP🍏🍉🍌🍓🍊🍇
Coming at you again with another high protein snack idea! I made a peanut butter fruit dip by mixing together vanilla greek yogurt and pbfit😋 I love this dip with apple slices🍎 This has definitely been my new go to lately, especially when I have a sweet tooth. Let me know if you decide to try this o
kaitlyn ✿

kaitlyn ✿

818 likes

High protein Snickers Blizzard!
Thick and creamy, nourishing, protein packed snickers blizzard! This feels like SUCH a treat, but it's loaded with feel good ingredients, hidden veggies, and protein! A must make for the sweet tooth fix while hitting those protein goals, too! #summerdessert #proteindessert #proteintrea
Colleen Forton

Colleen Forton

612 likes

NUTTER BUTTER PROTEIN ICE CREAM 🥜
I could eat this everyday, it’s that good! recipe below and macros at the end 🫶🏼 nutter butter cookie protein ice cream: 12oz water 1 scoop @pescience peanut butter cookie protein powder 2 tbsp powdered peanut butter 2 tbsp 0 sugar coffee creamer 1 package nutter butter bites directions
Meg Dopp

Meg Dopp

45 likes

See more